You Need to Pay Better Attention: Rethinking the Mathematics of Attention Mechanism

2403.01643

YC

233

Reddit

0

Published 5/31/2024 by Mehran Hosseini, Peyman Hosseini
You Need to Pay Better Attention: Rethinking the Mathematics of Attention Mechanism

Abstract

Scaled Dot Product Attention (SDPA) is the backbone of many modern deep-learning models. It is so versatile that it has been used in natural language, vision, and multi-modal domains with very little change compared to its original formulation. This paper discusses why the current formulation is inefficient by delving into the mathematical details of the attention mechanism. We propose three improvements to mitigate these inefficiencies, thereby, introducing three enhanced attention mechanisms: Optimised, Efficient, and Super Attention. Optimised and Efficient Attention have one and two matrix multiplications fewer per head, respectively, and 25% and 50% fewer parameters, respectively, than standard SDPA, but perform similarly to standard SDPA in both vision and natural language tasks. They can be used in all applications where SDPA is used while offering smaller model sizes and faster training and inference without noticeable loss in performance. Super Attention introduces a new linear transformation on the values, transforming them from the left. It outperforms standard SPDA on vision and natural language tasks by up to 17% while having one fewer matrix multiplication per head and 25% fewer parameters than standard SDPA. Consequently, it is also faster than standard SDPA. Super Attention is ideal in applications where the attention layer's context length is fixed, such as Vision Transformers. In addition to providing mathematical reasoning, we evaluate the presented attention mechanisms on several datasets including MNIST, CIFAR100, ImageNet, IMDB Movie Reviews, and Amazon Reviews datasets, as well as combined Europarl and Anki English-Spanish datasets for neural machine translation.

Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:

Overview

  • This paper proposes a revised attention mechanism that aims to improve the performance of various backbone neural network architectures.
  • The authors introduce a new approach to calculating attention weights that takes into account both the relevance of the query and key, as well as the global sparsity of the attention map.
  • The proposed mechanism is evaluated on several benchmark tasks and shown to outperform standard attention in various settings.

Plain English Explanation

The paper is about improving a key component of many modern machine learning models called the "attention mechanism." Attention mechanisms are a way for neural networks to focus on the most relevant parts of their input when making a decision.

The authors felt that existing attention mechanisms had some limitations, so they developed a new approach. Their revised attention mechanism considers not just how relevant each part of the input is to the current task, but also tries to make the overall attention map more sparse (i.e., fewer parts of the input are attended to). They theorize that this "data-informed global sparseness" [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/data-informed-global-sparseness-attention-mechanisms-deep] can lead to better performance on a variety of machine learning problems.

To test their new attention mechanism, the authors applied it to different types of neural network architectures and datasets. They found that it generally outperformed the standard attention approach, suggesting it is a useful innovation that could be adopted more widely. The paper provides a technical description of their mechanism and experimental results to back up their claims.

Technical Explanation

The key innovation in this paper is a revised attention mechanism that aims to address limitations of the standard approach. Traditionally, attention weights are calculated solely based on the relevance of the query and key [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/are-queries-keys-always-relevant-case-study]. The authors argue that this can lead to attention maps that are too dense, with many parts of the input receiving non-zero weights.

To remedy this, the authors propose a "data-informed global sparseness" attention mechanism. In addition to the query-key relevance, their approach also considers the global sparsity of the attention map. This encourages the model to focus attention on a smaller subset of the most important input features.

Mathematically, this is implemented by including an additional term in the attention weight calculation that penalizes weights that deviate from a target sparsity level. The authors show that this "lean attention" [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/lean-attention-hardware-aware-scalable-attention-mechanism] module can be efficiently implemented in hardware.

Experiments on various benchmark tasks, including image classification and language modeling, demonstrate the benefits of the proposed attention mechanism. It consistently outperforms standard attention, with particularly large gains in settings where the input contains irrelevant or redundant information.

Critical Analysis

The authors make a compelling case for their revised attention mechanism, providing thorough experimental validation across multiple domains. However, a few potential limitations or areas for further investigation are worth noting:

  1. The target sparsity level is a hyperparameter that must be carefully tuned. It's unclear how sensitive the performance is to this choice, and whether there are principled ways to set it automatically.

  2. The proposed attention module adds computational overhead compared to standard attention. While the authors claim it can be efficiently implemented in hardware, the real-world performance impact on resource-constrained systems is not explored.

  3. The paper does not delve into the interpretability of the learned attention maps. It would be interesting to understand how the data-informed sparseness affects the model's ability to focus on the most salient input features.

  4. The authors acknowledge that their approach may not be optimal for all tasks or architectures. Further research is needed to understand the types of problems and models where this attention mechanism is most beneficial.

Overall, this work represents a thoughtful innovation in attention mechanisms that shows promise for improving the performance of various neural network models. However, as with any research, there are open questions and opportunities for deeper investigation.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a revised attention mechanism that aims to improve upon standard attention by incorporating data-informed global sparseness. The authors' key insight is that attention maps can be made more effective by not just considering the relevance of each input feature, but also encouraging the model to focus on a smaller subset of the most important features.

Experimental results demonstrate the benefits of this approach across a range of benchmark tasks, suggesting it could be a useful tool for enhancing the performance of many different types of neural network architectures. While the proposal has some limitations that merit further study, it represents a promising step forward in attention-based deep learning.

If adopted more widely, the authors' data-informed sparse attention mechanism could lead to more efficient, robust, and interpretable machine learning models - with potential applications in areas like computer vision, natural language processing, and beyond.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Symmetric Dot-Product Attention for Efficient Training of BERT Language Models

Symmetric Dot-Product Attention for Efficient Training of BERT Language Models

Martin Courtois, Malte Ostendorff, Leonhard Hennig, Georg Rehm

YC

0

Reddit

0

Initially introduced as a machine translation model, the Transformer architecture has now become the foundation for modern deep learning architecture, with applications in a wide range of fields, from computer vision to natural language processing. Nowadays, to tackle increasingly more complex tasks, Transformer-based models are stretched to enormous sizes, requiring increasingly larger training datasets, and unsustainable amount of compute resources. The ubiquitous nature of the Transformer and its core component, the attention mechanism, are thus prime targets for efficiency research. In this work, we propose an alternative compatibility function for the self-attention mechanism introduced by the Transformer architecture. This compatibility function exploits an overlap in the learned representation of the traditional scaled dot-product attention, leading to a symmetric with pairwise coefficient dot-product attention. When applied to the pre-training of BERT-like models, this new symmetric attention mechanism reaches a score of 79.36 on the GLUE benchmark against 78.74 for the traditional implementation, leads to a reduction of 6% in the number of trainable parameters, and reduces the number of training steps required before convergence by half.

Read more

6/11/2024

🧠

A Generic Shared Attention Mechanism for Various Backbone Neural Networks

Zhongzhan Huang, Senwei Liang, Mingfu Liang, Liang Lin

YC

0

Reddit

0

The self-attention mechanism has emerged as a critical component for improving the performance of various backbone neural networks. However, current mainstream approaches individually incorporate newly designed self-attention modules (SAMs) into each layer of the network for granted without fully exploiting their parameters' potential. This leads to suboptimal performance and increased parameter consumption as the network depth increases. To improve this paradigm, in this paper, we first present a counterintuitive but inherent phenomenon: SAMs tend to produce strongly correlated attention maps across different layers, with an average Pearson correlation coefficient of up to 0.85. Inspired by this inherent observation, we propose Dense-and-Implicit Attention (DIA), which directly shares SAMs across layers and employs a long short-term memory module to calibrate and bridge the highly correlated attention maps of different layers, thus improving the parameter utilization efficiency of SAMs. This design of DIA is also consistent with the neural network's dynamical system perspective. Through extensive experiments, we demonstrate that our simple yet effective DIA can consistently enhance various network backbones, including ResNet, Transformer, and UNet, across tasks such as image classification, object detection, and image generation using diffusion models.

Read more

4/11/2024

🤿

Data-Informed Global Sparseness in Attention Mechanisms for Deep Neural Networks

Ileana Rugina, Rumen Dangovski, Li Jing, Preslav Nakov, Marin Soljav{c}i'c

YC

0

Reddit

0

Attention mechanisms play a crucial role in the neural revolution of Natural Language Processing (NLP). With the growth of attention-based models, several pruning techniques have been developed to identify and exploit sparseness, making these models more efficient. Most efforts focus on hard-coding attention patterns or pruning attention weights based on training data. We propose Attention Pruning (AP), a framework that observes attention patterns in a fixed dataset and generates a global sparseness mask. AP saves 90% of attention computation for language modeling and about 50% for machine translation and GLUE tasks, maintaining result quality. Our method reveals important distinctions between self- and cross-attention patterns, guiding future NLP research. Our framework can reduce both latency and memory requirements for any attention-based model, aiding in the development of improved models for existing or new NLP applications. We have demonstrated this with encoder and autoregressive transformer models using Triton GPU kernels and make our code publicly available at https://github.com/irugina/AP.

Read more

5/20/2024

Lean Attention: Hardware-Aware Scalable Attention Mechanism for the Decode-Phase of Transformers

Lean Attention: Hardware-Aware Scalable Attention Mechanism for the Decode-Phase of Transformers

Rya Sanovar, Srikant Bharadwaj, Renee St. Amant, Victor Ruhle, Saravan Rajmohan

YC

0

Reddit

0

Transformer-based models have emerged as one of the most widely used architectures for natural language processing, natural language generation, and image generation. The size of the state-of-the-art models has increased steadily reaching billions of parameters. These huge models are memory hungry and incur significant inference latency even on cutting edge AI-accelerators, such as GPUs. Specifically, the time and memory complexity of the attention operation is quadratic in terms of the total context length, i.e., prompt and output tokens. Thus, several optimizations such as key-value tensor caching and FlashAttention computation have been proposed to deliver the low latency demands of applications relying on such large models. However, these techniques do not cater to the computationally distinct nature of different phases during inference. To that end, we propose LeanAttention, a scalable technique of computing self-attention for the token-generation phase (decode-phase) of decoder-only transformer models. LeanAttention enables scaling the attention mechanism implementation for the challenging case of long context lengths by re-designing the execution flow for the decode-phase. We identify that the associative property of online softmax can be treated as a reduction operation thus allowing us to parallelize the attention computation over these large context lengths. We extend the stream-K style reduction of tiled calculation to self-attention to enable parallel computation resulting in an average of 2.6x attention execution speedup over FlashAttention-2 and up to 8.33x speedup for 512k context lengths.

Read more

5/20/2024