Training Language Models to Generate Text with Citations via Fine-grained Rewards

2402.04315

YC

170

Reddit

0

Published 5/28/2024 by Chengyu Huang, Zeqiu Wu, Yushi Hu, Wenya Wang
Training Language Models to Generate Text with Citations via Fine-grained Rewards

Abstract

While recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have proven useful in answering user queries, they are prone to hallucination, and their responses often lack credibility due to missing references to reliable sources. An intuitive solution to these issues would be to include in-text citations referring to external documents as evidence. While previous works have directly prompted LLMs to generate in-text citations, their performances are far from satisfactory, especially when it comes to smaller LLMs. In this work, we propose an effective training framework using fine-grained rewards to teach LLMs to generate highly supportive and relevant citations, while ensuring the correctness of their responses. We also conduct a systematic analysis of applying these fine-grained rewards to common LLM training strategies, demonstrating its advantage over conventional practices. We conduct extensive experiments on Question Answering (QA) datasets taken from the ALCE benchmark and validate the model's generalizability using EXPERTQA. On LLaMA-2-7B, the incorporation of fine-grained rewards achieves the best performance among the baselines, even surpassing that of GPT-3.5-turbo.

Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:

Overview

  • This paper presents a method for training language models to generate text with accurate citations to external sources.
  • The approach uses fine-grained rewards based on evaluating the correctness and relevance of citations during the text generation process.
  • The authors demonstrate improvements in citation quality and faithfulness to source material compared to baseline language models.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a way to train language models, like the ones used in AI assistants, to generate text that includes proper citations to external sources. This work builds on previous research on improving language model performance and grounding through citation generation.

The key idea is to provide the model with detailed feedback, or "rewards," during training based on how well the citations it generates match the source material. This "fine-grained" reward signal helps the model learn to produce text that cites relevant sources accurately, rather than just generating citations randomly or inaccurately.

By training the model this way, the authors show it is able to produce text with better quality and more faithful citations compared to standard language models. This could be useful for applications like academic writing assistance, fact-checking, or generating summaries that properly attribute information to sources.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a method for fine-tuning large language models to generate text with accurate citations. The approach involves defining a set of fine-grained rewards that evaluate the correctness and relevance of citations produced by the model during text generation.

The rewards cover aspects like:

  • Whether the cited source is relevant to the generated text
  • If the citation accurately reflects the content of the source
  • If the citation is placed in the appropriate location within the generated text

These rewards are used to guide the model's training, providing more granular feedback than just evaluating the overall quality of the generated text.

The authors experiment with this approach using the GPT-3 language model as a starting point, and demonstrate improvements in citation quality and faithfulness compared to baseline models. This builds on prior work on enhancing language models through citation-based training and grounding.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a promising approach for improving the citation abilities of large language models. The fine-grained rewards seem well-designed to push the model towards generating more accurate and relevant citations.

However, the authors acknowledge some limitations. The training process is computationally intensive, requiring multiple rounds of fine-tuning. There are also open questions around how to scale this approach to broader domains beyond the specific dataset used in the experiments.

Additional research would be needed to explore the generalization of this method, its robustness to adversarial attacks, and its performance in real-world applications like academic writing assistance. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step towards building language models that can reliably cite sources and ground their generated text in external evidence.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach for training language models to generate text with accurate and relevant citations. By defining fine-grained rewards that assess the quality of citations during the text generation process, the authors demonstrate improvements in citation faithfulness compared to standard language models.

This work has the potential to enable more reliable and trustworthy text generation in applications like academic writing, journalism, and knowledge summarization. Further research is needed to explore the scalability and real-world performance of this method, but it represents an important advance in the field of citation-aware language modeling.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Context-Enhanced Language Models for Generating Multi-Paper Citations

Context-Enhanced Language Models for Generating Multi-Paper Citations

Avinash Anand, Kritarth Prasad, Ujjwal Goel, Mohit Gupta, Naman Lal, Astha Verma, Rajiv Ratn Shah

YC

0

Reddit

0

Citation text plays a pivotal role in elucidating the connection between scientific documents, demanding an in-depth comprehension of the cited paper. Constructing citations is often time-consuming, requiring researchers to delve into extensive literature and grapple with articulating relevant content. To address this challenge, the field of citation text generation (CTG) has emerged. However, while earlier methods have primarily centered on creating single-sentence citations, practical scenarios frequently necessitate citing multiple papers within a single paragraph. To bridge this gap, we propose a method that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate multi-citation sentences. Our approach involves a single source paper and a collection of target papers, culminating in a coherent paragraph containing multi-sentence citation text. Furthermore, we introduce a curated dataset named MCG-S2ORC, composed of English-language academic research papers in Computer Science, showcasing multiple citation instances. In our experiments, we evaluate three LLMs LLaMA, Alpaca, and Vicuna to ascertain the most effective model for this endeavor. Additionally, we exhibit enhanced performance by integrating knowledge graphs from target papers into the prompts for generating citation text. This research underscores the potential of harnessing LLMs for citation generation, opening a compelling avenue for exploring the intricate connections between scientific documents.

Read more

4/23/2024

Aligning Large Language Models via Fine-grained Supervision

Aligning Large Language Models via Fine-grained Supervision

Dehong Xu, Liang Qiu, Minseok Kim, Faisal Ladhak, Jaeyoung Do

YC

0

Reddit

0

Pre-trained large-scale language models (LLMs) excel at producing coherent articles, yet their outputs may be untruthful, toxic, or fail to align with user expectations. Current approaches focus on using reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) to improve model alignment, which works by transforming coarse human preferences of LLM outputs into a feedback signal that guides the model learning process. However, because this approach operates on sequence-level feedback, it lacks the precision to identify the exact parts of the output affecting user preferences. To address this gap, we propose a method to enhance LLM alignment through fine-grained token-level supervision. Specifically, we ask annotators to minimally edit less preferred responses within the standard reward modeling dataset to make them more favorable, ensuring changes are made only where necessary while retaining most of the original content. The refined dataset is used to train a token-level reward model, which is then used for training our fine-grained Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) model. Our experiment results demonstrate that this approach can achieve up to an absolute improvement of $5.1%$ in LLM performance, in terms of win rate against the reference model, compared with the traditional PPO model.

Read more

6/6/2024

Verifiable Generation with Subsentence-Level Fine-Grained Citations

Verifiable Generation with Subsentence-Level Fine-Grained Citations

Shuyang Cao, Lu Wang

YC

0

Reddit

0

Verifiable generation requires large language models (LLMs) to cite source documents supporting their outputs, thereby improve output transparency and trustworthiness. Yet, previous work mainly targets the generation of sentence-level citations, lacking specificity about which parts of a sentence are backed by the cited sources. This work studies verifiable generation with subsentence-level fine-grained citations for more precise location of generated content supported by the cited sources. We first present a dataset, SCiFi, comprising 10K Wikipedia paragraphs with subsentence-level citations. Each paragraph is paired with a set of candidate source documents for citation and a query that triggers the generation of the paragraph content. On SCiFi, we evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art LLMs and strategies for processing long documents designed for these models. Our experiment results reveals key factors that could enhance the quality of citations, including the expansion of the source documents' context accessible to the models and the implementation of specialized model tuning.

Read more

6/11/2024

💬

Effective Large Language Model Adaptation for Improved Grounding and Citation Generation

Xi Ye, Ruoxi Sun, Sercan O. Arik, Tomas Pfister

YC

0

Reddit

0

Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements in natural language understanding and generation. However, one major issue towards their widespread deployment in the real world is that they can generate hallucinated answers that are not factual. Towards this end, this paper focuses on improving LLMs by grounding their responses in retrieved passages and by providing citations. We propose a new framework, AGREE, Adaptation for GRounding EnhancEment, that improves the grounding from a holistic perspective. Our framework tunes LLMs to selfground the claims in their responses and provide accurate citations to retrieved documents. This tuning on top of the pre-trained LLMs requires well-grounded responses (with citations) for paired queries, for which we introduce a method that can automatically construct such data from unlabeled queries. The selfgrounding capability of tuned LLMs further grants them a test-time adaptation (TTA) capability that can actively retrieve passages to support the claims that have not been grounded, which iteratively improves the responses of LLMs. Across five datasets and two LLMs, our results show that the proposed tuningbased AGREE framework generates superior grounded responses with more accurate citations compared to prompting-based approaches and post-hoc citing-based approaches

Read more

4/4/2024