Towards Compositionally Generalizable Semantic Parsing in Large Language Models: A Survey

2404.13074

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/23/2024 by Amogh Mannekote

šŸ’¬

Abstract

Compositional generalization is the ability of a model to generalize to complex, previously unseen types of combinations of entities from just having seen the primitives. This type of generalization is particularly relevant to the semantic parsing community for applications such as task-oriented dialogue, text-to-SQL parsing, and information retrieval, as they can harbor infinite complexity. Despite the success of large language models (LLMs) in a wide range of NLP tasks, unlocking perfect compositional generalization still remains one of the few last unsolved frontiers. The past few years has seen a surge of interest in works that explore the limitations of, methods to improve, and evaluation metrics for compositional generalization capabilities of LLMs for semantic parsing tasks. In this work, we present a literature survey geared at synthesizing recent advances in analysis, methods, and evaluation schemes to offer a starting point for both practitioners and researchers in this area.

Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:

Overview

  • This paper provides a comprehensive survey on the topic of achieving compositionally generalizable semantic parsing in large language models.
  • Compositional generalization refers to the ability of a model to understand and generate novel combinations of known concepts, rather than just memorizing specific examples.
  • The paper explores how to define and evaluate compositional generalization in the context of semantic parsing, which involves translating natural language into formal representations like database queries or computer programs.

Plain English Explanation

Semantic parsing is the process of taking a piece of natural language, like a sentence or question, and converting it into a formal, machine-readable representation. This is an important capability for many AI applications, from language understanding to question answering.

One key challenge in semantic parsing is achieving compositional generalization. This means that the model can understand and generate novel combinations of concepts, rather than just memorizing a fixed set of examples. For example, if a model is trained on questions about the population of cities, it should be able to also understand and answer questions about the capital cities of countries, even if it has never seen that specific combination before.

This survey paper explores how researchers are working to improve the compositional generalization abilities of large language models when it comes to semantic parsing tasks. The authors discuss different ways to define and measure compositional generalization, as well as various techniques that have been proposed to enhance this capability, such as iterated learning, multi-aspect controllable generation, and interactive learning.

By improving compositional generalization in semantic parsing, the hope is that these models will be able to better understand and respond to a wider range of natural language inputs, beyond just what they were specifically trained on. This could lead to more robust and capable language AI systems.

Technical Explanation

The paper first discusses how to define and evaluate compositional generalization in the context of semantic parsing. The authors propose a framework based on the notion of "systematicity," which captures the idea that the model should be able to understand and generate novel combinations of known concepts.

They then survey various techniques that have been explored to improve compositional generalization in semantic parsing. These include:

  1. Architectural Approaches: Modifying the model architecture, such as incorporating relational reasoning modules, to better capture the compositional structure of language.

  2. Training Approaches: Employing techniques like iterated learning and multi-aspect controllable generation to encourage the model to learn more generalizable representations.

  3. Interactive Learning: Allowing the model to learn through an interactive process, where it can ask clarifying questions and receive feedback, as explored in this work.

  4. Probing and Benchmarking: Developing specialized datasets and evaluation metrics to better understand and measure the compositional generalization abilities of semantic parsing models.

The paper also discusses some of the challenges and limitations of the current approaches, such as the difficulty of scaling interactive learning to larger models and datasets. It suggests that further research is needed to truly unlock the potential of large language models for compositionally generalizable semantic parsing.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough and well-structured survey of the current state of research on compositional generalization in semantic parsing. The authors do a good job of highlighting the key challenges and identifying the most promising directions for future work.

One potential limitation of the survey is that it focuses primarily on techniques that have been explored within the semantic parsing domain. It would be interesting to see the authors also discuss how ideas from other areas of language AI, such as development of compositionality and generalization through interactive learning or improving capabilities of large language models for marketing, could be applied or adapted to the semantic parsing problem.

Additionally, while the paper covers a wide range of relevant research, there may be other interesting approaches or perspectives that are not included. A more comprehensive survey could potentially uncover additional insights or avenues for exploration.

Overall, this survey provides a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners working on improving the compositional generalization abilities of large language models in semantic parsing and related areas of natural language processing.

Conclusion

This paper presents a comprehensive survey on the topic of achieving compositionally generalizable semantic parsing in large language models. It defines the key concepts of compositional generalization, explores various techniques that have been proposed to enhance this capability, and discusses the current challenges and limitations of the field.

By improving the compositional generalization of semantic parsing models, researchers hope to develop more robust and versatile language AI systems that can better understand and respond to natural language inputs. The survey highlights the importance of this line of research and the potential impact it could have on a wide range of applications, from question answering to task-oriented dialogue.

As the field of natural language processing continues to advance, the ability to achieve compositional generalization will likely become increasingly crucial. This survey provides a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners working to push the boundaries of what is possible with large language models.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

šŸ’¬

Compositional Generalization with Grounded Language Models

Sondre Wold, 'Etienne Simon, Lucas Georges Gabriel Charpentier, Egor V. Kostylev, Erik Velldal, Lilja {O}vrelid

YC

0

Reddit

0

Grounded language models use external sources of information, such as knowledge graphs, to meet some of the general challenges associated with pre-training. By extending previous work on compositional generalization in semantic parsing, we allow for a controlled evaluation of the degree to which these models learn and generalize from patterns in knowledge graphs. We develop a procedure for generating natural language questions paired with knowledge graphs that targets different aspects of compositionality and further avoids grounding the language models in information already encoded implicitly in their weights. We evaluate existing methods for combining language models with knowledge graphs and find them to struggle with generalization to sequences of unseen lengths and to novel combinations of seen base components. While our experimental results provide some insight into the expressive power of these models, we hope our work and released datasets motivate future research on how to better combine language models with structured knowledge representations.

Read more

6/10/2024

A General Theory for Compositional Generalization

A General Theory for Compositional Generalization

Jingwen Fu, Zhizheng Zhang, Yan Lu, Nanning Zheng

YC

0

Reddit

0

Compositional Generalization (CG) embodies the ability to comprehend novel combinations of familiar concepts, representing a significant cognitive leap in human intellectual advancement. Despite its critical importance, the deep neural network (DNN) faces challenges in addressing the compositional generalization problem, prompting considerable research interest. However, existing theories often rely on task-specific assumptions, constraining the comprehensive understanding of CG. This study aims to explore compositional generalization from a task-agnostic perspective, offering a complementary viewpoint to task-specific analyses. The primary challenge is to define CG without overly restricting its scope, a feat achieved by identifying its fundamental characteristics and basing the definition on them. Using this definition, we seek to answer the question what does the ultimate solution to CG look like? through the following theoretical findings: 1) the first No Free Lunch theorem in CG, indicating the absence of general solutions; 2) a novel generalization bound applicable to any CG problem, specifying the conditions for an effective CG solution; and 3) the introduction of the generative effect to enhance understanding of CG problems and their solutions. This paper's significance lies in providing a general theory for CG problems, which, when combined with prior theorems under task-specific scenarios, can lead to a comprehensive understanding of CG.

Read more

5/21/2024

Sequential Compositional Generalization in Multimodal Models

Sequential Compositional Generalization in Multimodal Models

Semih Yagcioglu, Osman Batur .Ince, Aykut Erdem, Erkut Erdem, Desmond Elliott, Deniz Yuret

YC

0

Reddit

0

The rise of large-scale multimodal models has paved the pathway for groundbreaking advances in generative modeling and reasoning, unlocking transformative applications in a variety of complex tasks. However, a pressing question that remains is their genuine capability for stronger forms of generalization, which has been largely underexplored in the multimodal setting. Our study aims to address this by examining sequential compositional generalization using textsc{CompAct} (underline{Comp}ositional underline{Act}ivities)footnote{Project Page: url{http://cyberiada.github.io/CompAct}}, a carefully constructed, perceptually grounded dataset set within a rich backdrop of egocentric kitchen activity videos. Each instance in our dataset is represented with a combination of raw video footage, naturally occurring sound, and crowd-sourced step-by-step descriptions. More importantly, our setup ensures that the individual concepts are consistently distributed across training and evaluation sets, while their compositions are novel in the evaluation set. We conduct a comprehensive assessment of several unimodal and multimodal models. Our findings reveal that bi-modal and tri-modal models exhibit a clear edge over their text-only counterparts. This highlights the importance of multimodality while charting a trajectory for future research in this domain.

Read more

4/19/2024

šŸ’¬

Exploring the Compositional Deficiency of Large Language Models in Mathematical Reasoning

Jun Zhao, Jingqi Tong, Yurong Mou, Ming Zhang, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang

YC

0

Reddit

0

Human cognition exhibits systematic compositionality, the algebraic ability to generate infinite novel combinations from finite learned components, which is the key to understanding and reasoning about complex logic. In this work, we investigate the compositionality of large language models (LLMs) in mathematical reasoning. Specifically, we construct a new dataset textsc{MathTrap}footnotemark[3] by introducing carefully designed logical traps into the problem descriptions of MATH and GSM8k. Since problems with logical flaws are quite rare in the real world, these represent ``unseen'' cases to LLMs. Solving these requires the models to systematically compose (1) the mathematical knowledge involved in the original problems with (2) knowledge related to the introduced traps. Our experiments show that while LLMs possess both components of requisite knowledge, they do not textbf{spontaneously} combine them to handle these novel cases. We explore several methods to mitigate this deficiency, such as natural language prompts, few-shot demonstrations, and fine-tuning. We find that LLMs' performance can be textbf{passively} improved through the above external intervention. Overall, systematic compositionality remains an open challenge for large language models.

Read more

5/14/2024