# Thermodynamic Natural Gradient Descent

2405.13817

200

0

🌿

## Abstract

Second-order training methods have better convergence properties than gradient descent but are rarely used in practice for large-scale training due to their computational overhead. This can be viewed as a hardware limitation (imposed by digital computers). Here we show that natural gradient descent (NGD), a second-order method, can have a similar computational complexity per iteration to a first-order method, when employing appropriate hardware. We present a new hybrid digital-analog algorithm for training neural networks that is equivalent to NGD in a certain parameter regime but avoids prohibitively costly linear system solves. Our algorithm exploits the thermodynamic properties of an analog system at equilibrium, and hence requires an analog thermodynamic computer. The training occurs in a hybrid digital-analog loop, where the gradient and Fisher information matrix (or any other positive semi-definite curvature matrix) are calculated at given time intervals while the analog dynamics take place. We numerically demonstrate the superiority of this approach over state-of-the-art digital first- and second-order training methods on classification tasks and language model fine-tuning tasks.

Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:

## Overview

- Second-order training methods like natural gradient descent have better convergence properties than first-order gradient descent, but are rarely used for large-scale training due to their computational overhead.
- This paper presents a new hybrid digital-analog algorithm for training neural networks that is equivalent to natural gradient descent in a certain parameter regime, but avoids the costly linear system solves.
- The algorithm exploits the thermodynamic properties of an analog system at equilibrium, requiring an analog thermodynamic computer.
- The training occurs in a hybrid digital-analog loop, where the gradient and curvature information are calculated digitally while the analog dynamics take place.
- The authors demonstrate the superiority of this approach over state-of-the-art digital first- and second-order training methods on classification and language modeling tasks.

## Plain English Explanation

Training machine learning models, especially large neural networks, is a complex and computationally intensive process. The most common approach, called gradient descent, updates the model's parameters by following the direction that reduces the error the fastest. However, gradient descent can be slow to converge, meaning it takes a long time to find the best set of parameters.

An alternative approach called natural gradient descent has been shown to converge faster, but it requires more complex calculations that are too slow for practical use on large models. This paper introduces a new hybrid method that combines digital and analog computing to get the benefits of natural gradient descent without the computational overhead.

The key idea is to use a special analog hardware device, called an "analog thermodynamic computer," to handle the most computationally intensive parts of the natural gradient descent algorithm. This analog device can perform the necessary calculations much faster than a traditional digital computer. The training process then alternates between the digital and analog components, with the digital part calculating the gradients and other information, and the analog part updating the model parameters.

The authors show that this hybrid approach outperforms state-of-the-art digital training methods on several benchmark tasks, demonstrating the potential of combining analog and digital computing for efficient model training.

## Technical Explanation

The paper presents a new hybrid digital-analog algorithm for training neural networks that is equivalent to natural gradient descent in a certain parameter regime. Natural gradient descent is a second-order training method that can have better convergence properties than first-order gradient descent, but is rarely used in practice due to its high computational cost.

The key innovation of this work is the use of an analog thermodynamic computer to perform the most computationally intensive parts of the natural gradient descent algorithm. The training process alternates between digital and analog components:

- The digital component calculates the gradient and Fisher information matrix (or any other positive semi-definite curvature matrix) at given time intervals.
- The analog component then updates the model parameters using the thermodynamic properties of the analog system at equilibrium, avoiding the need for costly linear system solves.

This hybrid approach is shown to be equivalent to natural gradient descent in a certain parameter regime, but with a computational complexity per iteration that is similar to a first-order method.

The authors numerically demonstrate the superiority of this hybrid digital-analog approach over state-of-the-art digital first-order methods like approximate gradient descent and second-order methods like Gauss-Newton optimization on classification tasks and language model fine-tuning. They also discuss the potential of combining analog and digital computing to efficiently train large-scale neural networks, highlighting the importance of automatic differentiation in enabling this hybrid approach.

## Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach for improving the efficiency of training large neural networks by leveraging analog computing hardware. The key advantage of this hybrid digital-analog method is that it can achieve the convergence benefits of natural gradient descent without the prohibitive computational cost.

However, the practical implementation of this approach may face some challenges. The requirement of an analog thermodynamic computer, which is likely a specialized and expensive piece of hardware, could limit the accessibility and widespread adoption of this technique. Additionally, the integration and synchronization between the digital and analog components may introduce additional complexity and potential sources of error.

Furthermore, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the limitations or failure modes of the analog component. It would be helpful to understand the sensitivity of the analog system to factors like noise, temperature fluctuations, or parameter variations, and how these might impact the overall training performance.

Another area for further exploration is the scalability of this approach to increasingly large and complex neural network architectures. The authors demonstrate the benefits on relatively small-scale tasks, but it remains to be seen how well the hybrid digital-analog method would scale as the model size and complexity grow.

Despite these potential challenges, the paper represents an exciting step towards bridging the gap between the theoretical advantages of second-order training methods and their practical applicability. The use of analog computing to accelerate certain computationally intensive operations is a promising direction for improving the efficiency of machine learning training, and this work serves as a valuable contribution to this emerging field.

## Conclusion

This paper presents a novel hybrid digital-analog algorithm for training neural networks that combines the convergence benefits of natural gradient descent with the computational efficiency of first-order methods. By exploiting the thermodynamic properties of an analog system, the authors have developed a training approach that avoids the costly linear system solves typically associated with second-order optimization techniques.

The demonstrated superiority of this hybrid method over state-of-the-art digital training approaches highlights the potential of combining analog and digital computing to improve the efficiency of large-scale machine learning. While the practical implementation may face some challenges, this work serves as an important stepping stone towards more efficient and scalable training of complex neural network models.

As the field of machine learning continues to advance, the integration of novel hardware architectures, such as the analog thermodynamic computer used in this work, will likely play an increasingly important role in overcoming the computational limitations of traditional digital systems. This paper provides a valuable contribution to this growing area of research and opens up new avenues for further exploration and innovation.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

## Related Papers

### Inverse-Free Fast Natural Gradient Descent Method for Deep Learning

Xinwei Ou, Ce Zhu, Xiaolin Huang, Yipeng Liu

0

0

Second-order optimization techniques have the potential to achieve faster convergence rates compared to first-order methods through the incorporation of second-order derivatives or statistics. However, their utilization in deep learning is limited due to their computational inefficiency. Various approaches have been proposed to address this issue, primarily centered on minimizing the size of the matrix to be inverted. Nevertheless, the necessity of performing the inverse operation iteratively persists. In this work, we present a fast natural gradient descent (FNGD) method that only requires inversion during the first epoch. Specifically, it is revealed that natural gradient descent (NGD) is essentially a weighted sum of per-sample gradients. Our novel approach further proposes to share these weighted coefficients across epochs without affecting empirical performance. Consequently, FNGD exhibits similarities to the average sum in first-order methods, leading to the computational complexity of FNGD being comparable to that of first-order methods. Extensive experiments on image classification and machine translation tasks demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed FNGD. For training ResNet-18 on CIFAR-100, FNGD can achieve a speedup of 2.07$times$ compared with KFAC. For training Transformer on Multi30K, FNGD outperforms AdamW by 24 BLEU score while requiring almost the same training time.

4/30/2024

🏋️

### Approximation and Gradient Descent Training with Neural Networks

G. Welper

0

0

It is well understood that neural networks with carefully hand-picked weights provide powerful function approximation and that they can be successfully trained in over-parametrized regimes. Since over-parametrization ensures zero training error, these two theories are not immediately compatible. Recent work uses the smoothness that is required for approximation results to extend a neural tangent kernel (NTK) optimization argument to an under-parametrized regime and show direct approximation bounds for networks trained by gradient flow. Since gradient flow is only an idealization of a practical method, this paper establishes analogous results for networks trained by gradient descent.

5/21/2024

🛠️

### Exact Gauss-Newton Optimization for Training Deep Neural Networks

Mikalai Korbit, Adeyemi D. Adeoye, Alberto Bemporad, Mario Zanon

0

0

We present EGN, a stochastic second-order optimization algorithm that combines the generalized Gauss-Newton (GN) Hessian approximation with low-rank linear algebra to compute the descent direction. Leveraging the Duncan-Guttman matrix identity, the parameter update is obtained by factorizing a matrix which has the size of the mini-batch. This is particularly advantageous for large-scale machine learning problems where the dimension of the neural network parameter vector is several orders of magnitude larger than the batch size. Additionally, we show how improvements such as line search, adaptive regularization, and momentum can be seamlessly added to EGN to further accelerate the algorithm. Moreover, under mild assumptions, we prove that our algorithm converges to an $epsilon$-stationary point at a linear rate. Finally, our numerical experiments demonstrate that EGN consistently exceeds, or at most matches the generalization performance of well-tuned SGD, Adam, and SGN optimizers across various supervised and reinforcement learning tasks.

5/24/2024

🧠

### Hybrid Quantum-Classical Scheduling for Accelerating Neural Network Training with Newton's Gradient Descent

Pingzhi Li, Junyu Liu, Hanrui Wang, Tianlong Chen

0

0

Optimization techniques in deep learning are predominantly led by first-order gradient methodologies, such as SGD. However, neural network training can greatly benefit from the rapid convergence characteristics of second-order optimization. Newton's GD stands out in this category, by rescaling the gradient using the inverse Hessian. Nevertheless, one of its major bottlenecks is matrix inversion, which is notably time-consuming in $O(N^3)$ time with weak scalability. Matrix inversion can be translated into solving a series of linear equations. Given that quantum linear solver algorithms (QLSAs), leveraging the principles of quantum superposition and entanglement, can operate within a $text{polylog}(N)$ time frame, they present a promising approach with exponential acceleration. Specifically, one of the most recent QLSAs demonstrates a complexity scaling of $O(dcdotkappa log(Ncdotkappa/epsilon))$, depending on: {size~$N$, condition number~$kappa$, error tolerance~$epsilon$, quantum oracle sparsity~$d$} of the matrix. However, this also implies that their potential exponential advantage may be hindered by certain properties (i.e. $kappa$ and $d$). We propose Q-Newton, a hybrid quantum-classical scheduler for accelerating neural network training with Newton's GD. Q-Newton utilizes a streamlined scheduling module that coordinates between quantum and classical linear solvers, by estimating & reducing $kappa$ and constructing $d$ for the quantum solver. Our evaluation showcases the potential for Q-Newton to significantly reduce the total training time compared to commonly used optimizers like SGD. We hypothesize a future scenario where the gate time of quantum machines is reduced, possibly realized by attoseconds physics. Our evaluation establishes an ambitious and promising target for the evolution of quantum computing.

5/2/2024