Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling

2406.02528

YC

199

Reddit

0

Published 6/12/2024 by Rui-Jie Zhu, Yu Zhang, Ethan Sifferman, Tyler Sheaves, Yiqiao Wang, Dustin Richmond, Peng Zhou, Jason K. Eshraghian
Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling

Abstract

Matrix multiplication (MatMul) typically dominates the overall computational cost of large language models (LLMs). This cost only grows as LLMs scale to larger embedding dimensions and context lengths. In this work, we show that MatMul operations can be completely eliminated from LLMs while maintaining strong performance at billion-parameter scales. Our experiments show that our proposed MatMul-free models achieve performance on-par with state-of-the-art Transformers that require far more memory during inference at a scale up to at least 2.7B parameters. We investigate the scaling laws and find that the performance gap between our MatMul-free models and full precision Transformers narrows as the model size increases. We also provide a GPU-efficient implementation of this model which reduces memory usage by up to 61% over an unoptimized baseline during training. By utilizing an optimized kernel during inference, our model's memory consumption can be reduced by more than 10x compared to unoptimized models. To properly quantify the efficiency of our architecture, we build a custom hardware solution on an FPGA which exploits lightweight operations beyond what GPUs are capable of. We processed billion-parameter scale models at 13W beyond human readable throughput, moving LLMs closer to brain-like efficiency. This work not only shows how far LLMs can be stripped back while still performing effectively, but also points at the types of operations future accelerators should be optimized for in processing the next generation of lightweight LLMs. Our code implementation is available at https://github.com/ridgerchu/matmulfreellm.

Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:

Overview

  • This paper presents a novel language modeling approach that avoids the computationally expensive matrix multiplication (MatMul) operations typically used in transformer-based models.
  • The proposed method, called Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling, aims to improve the efficiency and scalability of large language models without sacrificing performance.
  • Key innovations include the use of Transformer-Lite and Integer-only Inference techniques to enable efficient model execution.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a new way to build large language models, such as those used in chatbots and text generation, that is more efficient and scalable than traditional approaches. Instead of relying on the computationally intensive matrix multiplication (MatMul) operations commonly used in transformer-based models, the researchers have developed a novel technique called Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling.

This new method uses a simplified version of the transformer architecture, called Transformer-Lite, and Integer-only Inference to perform language modeling tasks without the need for expensive matrix multiplication. By avoiding these computationally intensive operations, the model can run more efficiently, especially on resource-constrained devices like smartphones or embedded systems.

The key idea is to find alternative ways to perform the core language modeling tasks, such as predicting the next word in a sequence, without relying on matrix multiplication. This allows the model to be more scalable, as it can be deployed on a wider range of hardware and be used in more applications where efficiency is crucial.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a new language modeling approach called Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling, which aims to improve the efficiency and scalability of large language models without sacrificing performance.

The core innovation is the use of Transformer-Lite, a simplified version of the transformer architecture that avoids the computationally expensive matrix multiplication (MatMul) operations typically used in transformer-based models. Additionally, the researchers employ Integer-only Inference techniques to further optimize the model's execution.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on a range of language modeling benchmarks, including language models that can do arithmetic, word embedding tasks, and evaluations of computational energy performance. The results show that the Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling approach can achieve comparable or even better performance than traditional transformer-based models, while being significantly more efficient and scalable.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to improving the efficiency and scalability of large language models, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

  1. Generalization to More Complex Tasks: The experiments in the paper focus on relatively simple language modeling tasks, such as next-word prediction. It's unclear how well the Scalable MatMul-free approach would generalize to more complex natural language processing tasks, such as question answering or text summarization, which may require more sophisticated modeling capabilities.

  2. Hardware Dependence: The efficiency gains of the Scalable MatMul-free approach are likely to be highly dependent on the specific hardware and software environment in which the models are deployed. The authors should investigate the performance of their approach on a wider range of hardware platforms, including mobile and edge devices, to better understand its real-world applicability.

  3. Tradeoffs in Model Accuracy: While the paper demonstrates that the Scalable MatMul-free models can achieve comparable or even better performance than traditional transformer-based models, there may be inherent tradeoffs in model accuracy that need to be further explored. The authors should investigate the extent to which the efficiency gains come at the cost of model performance, especially on more complex tasks.

  4. Interpretability and Explanability: As with many modern neural network-based models, the Scalable MatMul-free approach may suffer from a lack of interpretability and explanability. The authors should consider ways to make the inner workings of their models more transparent and understandable, which could help build trust and adoption in real-world applications.

Overall, the Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling approach presented in this paper is a promising step towards more efficient and scalable large language models. However, further research and evaluation are needed to fully understand its capabilities, limitations, and potential tradeoffs.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel language modeling approach called Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling, which aims to improve the efficiency and scalability of large language models without sacrificing performance. The key innovations include the use of Transformer-Lite and Integer-only Inference techniques to enable efficient model execution by avoiding computationally expensive matrix multiplication operations.

The experimental results demonstrate that the Scalable MatMul-free approach can achieve comparable or even better performance than traditional transformer-based models, while being significantly more efficient and scalable. This has important implications for the deployment of large language models in a wide range of applications, especially on resource-constrained devices where efficiency is crucial.

However, the paper also highlights several potential limitations and areas for further research, such as the generalization to more complex tasks, the dependence on specific hardware and software environments, the potential tradeoffs in model accuracy, and the need for improved interpretability and explanability. Continued research and development in this direction could lead to even more efficient and capable language models that can be deployed more widely and have a greater impact on various real-world applications.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

ShiftAddLLM: Accelerating Pretrained LLMs via Post-Training Multiplication-Less Reparameterization

New!ShiftAddLLM: Accelerating Pretrained LLMs via Post-Training Multiplication-Less Reparameterization

Haoran You (Celine), Yipin Guo (Celine), Yichao Fu (Celine), Wei Zhou (Celine), Huihong Shi (Celine), Xiaofan Zhang (Celine), Souvik Kundu (Celine), Amir Yazdanbakhsh (Celine), Yingyan (Celine), Lin

YC

0

Reddit

0

Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive performance on language tasks but face challenges when deployed on resource-constrained devices due to their extensive parameters and reliance on dense multiplications, resulting in high memory demands and latency bottlenecks. Shift-and-add reparameterization offers a promising solution by replacing costly multiplications with hardware-friendly primitives in both the attention and multi-layer perceptron (MLP) layers of an LLM. However, current reparameterization techniques require training from scratch or full parameter fine-tuning to restore accuracy, which is resource-intensive for LLMs. To address this, we propose accelerating pretrained LLMs through post-training shift-and-add reparameterization, creating efficient multiplication-free models, dubbed ShiftAddLLM. Specifically, we quantize each weight matrix into binary matrices paired with group-wise scaling factors. The associated multiplications are reparameterized into (1) shifts between activations and scaling factors and (2) queries and adds according to the binary matrices. To reduce accuracy loss, we present a multi-objective optimization method to minimize both weight and output activation reparameterization errors. Additionally, based on varying sensitivity across layers to reparameterization, we develop an automated bit allocation strategy to further reduce memory usage and latency. Experiments on five LLM families and eight tasks consistently validate the effectiveness of ShiftAddLLM, achieving average perplexity improvements of 5.6 and 22.7 points at comparable or lower latency compared to the most competitive quantized LLMs at 3 and 2 bits, respectively, and more than 80% memory and energy reductions over the original LLMs. Codes and models are available at https://github.com/GATECH-EIC/ShiftAddLLM.

Read more

6/12/2024

šŸ’¬

Transformer-Lite: High-efficiency Deployment of Large Language Models on Mobile Phone GPUs

Luchang Li, Sheng Qian, Jie Lu, Lunxi Yuan, Rui Wang, Qin Xie

YC

0

Reddit

0

The Large Language Model (LLM) is widely employed for tasks such as intelligent assistants, text summarization, translation, and multi-modality on mobile phones. However, the current methods for on-device LLM deployment maintain slow inference speed, which causes poor user experience. To facilitate high-efficiency LLM deployment on device GPUs, we propose four optimization techniques: (a) a symbolic expression-based approach to support dynamic shape model inference; (b) operator optimizations and execution priority setting to enhance inference speed and reduce phone lagging; (c) an FP4 quantization method termed M0E4 to reduce dequantization overhead; (d) a sub-tensor-based technique to eliminate the need for copying KV cache after LLM inference. Furthermore, we implement these methods in our mobile inference engine, Transformer-Lite, which is compatible with both Qualcomm and MTK processors. We evaluated Transformer-Lite's performance using LLMs with varied architectures and parameters ranging from 2B to 14B. Specifically, we achieved prefill and decoding speeds of 121 token/s and 14 token/s for ChatGLM2 6B, and 330 token/s and 30 token/s for smaller Gemma 2B, respectively. Compared with CPU-based FastLLM and GPU-based MLC-LLM, our engine attains over 10x speedup for the prefill speed and 2~3x speedup for the decoding speed.

Read more

5/22/2024

An Open-Source Framework for Efficient Numerically-Tailored Computations

An Open-Source Framework for Efficient Numerically-Tailored Computations

Louis Ledoux, Marc Casas

YC

0

Reddit

0

We present a versatile open-source framework designed to facilitate efficient, numerically-tailored Matrix-Matrix Multiplications (MMMs). The framework offers two primary contributions: first, a fine-tuned, automated pipeline for arithmetic datapath generation, enabling highly customizable systolic MMM kernels; second, seamless integration of the generated kernels into user code, irrespective of the programming language employed, without necessitating modifications. The framework demonstrates a systematic enhancement in accuracy per energy cost across diverse High Performance Computing (HPC) workloads displaying a variety of numerical requirements, such as Artificial Intelligence (AI) inference and Sea Surface Height (SSH) computation. For AI inference, we consider a set of state-of-the-art neural network models, namely ResNet18, ResNet34, ResNet50, DenseNet121, DenseNet161, DenseNet169, and VGG11, in conjunction with two datasets, two computer formats, and 27 distinct intermediate arithmetic datapaths. Our approach consistently reduces energy consumption across all cases, with a notable example being the reduction by factors of $3.3times$ for IEEE754-32 and $1.4times$ for Bfloat16 during ImageNet inference with ResNet50. This is accomplished while maintaining accuracies of $82.3%$ and $86%$, comparable to those achieved with conventional Floating-Point Units (FPUs). In the context of SSH computation, our method achieves fully-reproducible results using double-precision words, surpassing the accuracy of conventional double- and quad-precision arithmetic in FPUs. Our approach enhances SSH computation accuracy by a minimum of $5times$ and $27times$ compared to IEEE754-64 and IEEE754-128, respectively, resulting in $5.6times$ and $15.1times$ improvements in accuracy per power cost.

Read more

6/6/2024

OccamLLM: Fast and Exact Language Model Arithmetic in a Single Step

New!OccamLLM: Fast and Exact Language Model Arithmetic in a Single Step

Owen Dugan, Donato Manuel Jimenez Beneto, Charlotte Loh, Zhuo Chen, Rumen Dangovski, Marin Soljav{c}i'c

YC

0

Reddit

0

Despite significant advancements in text generation and reasoning, Large Language Models (LLMs) still face challenges in accurately performing complex arithmetic operations. To achieve accurate calculations, language model systems often enable LLMs to generate code for arithmetic operations. However, this approach compromises speed and security and, if finetuning is involved, risks the language model losing prior capabilities. We propose a framework that enables exact arithmetic in textit{a single autoregressive step}, providing faster, more secure, and more interpretable LLM systems with arithmetic capabilities. We use the hidden states of an LLM to control a symbolic architecture which performs arithmetic. Our implementation using Llama 3 8B Instruct with OccamNet as a symbolic model (OccamLlama) achieves 100% accuracy on single arithmetic operations ($+,-,times,div,sin{},cos{},log{},exp{},sqrt{}$), outperforming GPT 4o and on par with GPT 4o using a code interpreter. OccamLlama also outperforms both Llama 3 8B Instruct and GPT 3.5 Turbo on multistep reasoning problems involving challenging arithmetic, thus enabling small LLMs to match the arithmetic performance of even much larger models. We will make our code public shortly.

Read more

6/12/2024