Provably Efficient Bayesian Optimization with Unbiased Gaussian Process Hyperparameter Estimation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new method for Bayesian optimization that is provably efficient and uses unbiased Gaussian process hyperparameter estimation.
- Bayesian optimization is a technique for optimizing expensive-to-evaluate black-box functions, which is useful for tasks like hyperparameter tuning and high-precision motion system optimization.
- The key innovations in this work are an unbiased Gaussian process hyperparameter estimator and a new acquisition function that provably converges to the global optimum.
Plain English Explanation
Bayesian optimization is a powerful technique for finding the best settings of complex systems or machine learning models. It works by building a statistical model of the system and then using that model to guide the search for the optimal settings. However, a major challenge is accurately estimating the hyperparameters of the statistical model, which can significantly impact the optimization performance.
This paper presents a new Bayesian optimization method that addresses this challenge. The key idea is to use an unbiased estimator for the Gaussian process hyperparameters, which means the estimate is not systematically too high or too low. This helps the optimization process converge more reliably to the true global optimum.
The paper also introduces a new acquisition function, which is the criteria used to decide where to evaluate the expensive-to-compute function next. This new acquisition function is designed to provably lead to efficient optimization, meaning it is guaranteed to find the optimum in a reasonable number of steps.
By combining the unbiased hyperparameter estimation and the provably efficient acquisition function, this method represents an important advance in Bayesian optimization that could unlock new applications in fields like high-precision motion control and hyperparameter tuning.
Technical Explanation
The key technical contribution of this paper is a new Bayesian optimization algorithm that uses an unbiased Gaussian process (GP) hyperparameter estimator. Traditionally, hyperparameters of the GP model are estimated using maximum likelihood estimation, which can be biased, leading to suboptimal optimization performance.
The authors propose a novel unbiased estimator for the GP hyperparameters that corrects this bias. They show that this unbiased estimator, combined with a new acquisition function designed for provable convergence to the global optimum, results in a Bayesian optimization method that is both statistically efficient and computationally efficient.
Experimentally, the authors demonstrate the advantages of their method on a range of synthetic and real-world optimization problems, including hyperparameter tuning for Gaussian processes and Bayesian neural networks, as well as high-precision motion system optimization. They show that their method outperforms state-of-the-art Bayesian optimization techniques in terms of sample efficiency and ability to find the global optimum.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge several limitations of their work. First, the unbiased hyperparameter estimator relies on the assumption that the Gaussian process kernel function is known a priori, which may not always be the case in practice. Extensions to learn the kernel function as part of the optimization process would be valuable.
Additionally, the authors' theoretical analysis focuses on the case of a single global optimum. It would be interesting to see how the method performs in the presence of multiple local optima, which is a common challenge in real-world optimization problems.
The paper also does not address the issue of safe Bayesian optimization, where it is important to avoid evaluating the target function in unsafe regions. Incorporating safety constraints into the optimization framework could broaden the applicability of this approach.
Overall, this paper represents an important advance in Bayesian optimization by tackling the critical challenge of unbiased hyperparameter estimation. The proposed method demonstrates strong empirical performance and has the potential to unlock new applications, but further research is needed to address some of the remaining limitations.
Conclusion
This paper presents a new Bayesian optimization algorithm that uses an unbiased Gaussian process hyperparameter estimator and a provably efficient acquisition function. By addressing the bias in traditional hyperparameter estimation, the method achieves stronger optimization performance and reliability in finding the global optimum.
The innovations in this work could have significant implications for fields that rely on Bayesian optimization, such as hyperparameter tuning, high-precision motion control, and other complex optimization tasks. While the method has some limitations that warrant further research, it represents an important step forward in making Bayesian optimization more robust and widely applicable.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Provably Efficient Bayesian Optimization with Unbiased Gaussian Process Hyperparameter Estimation
Huong Ha, Vu Nguyen, Hung Tran-The, Hongyu Zhang, Xiuzhen Zhang, Anton van den Hengel
Gaussian process (GP) based Bayesian optimization (BO) is a powerful method for optimizing black-box functions efficiently. The practical performance and theoretical guarantees of this approach depend on having the correct GP hyperparameter values, which are usually unknown in advance and need to be estimated from the observed data. However, in practice, these estimations could be incorrect due to biased data sampling strategies used in BO. This can lead to degraded performance and break the sub-linear global convergence guarantee of BO. To address this issue, we propose a new BO method that can sub-linearly converge to the objective function's global optimum even when the true GP hyperparameters are unknown in advance and need to be estimated from the observed data. Our method uses a multi-armed bandit technique (EXP3) to add random data points to the BO process, and employs a novel training loss function for the GP hyperparameter estimation process that ensures consistent estimation. We further provide theoretical analysis of our proposed method. Finally, we demonstrate empirically that our method outperforms existing approaches on various synthetic and real-world problems.
Read more6/7/2024
🛠️
0
Pseudo-Bayesian Optimization
Haoxian Chen, Henry Lam
Bayesian Optimization is a popular approach for optimizing expensive black-box functions. Its key idea is to use a surrogate model to approximate the objective and, importantly, quantify the associated uncertainty that allows a sequential search of query points that balance exploitation-exploration. Gaussian process (GP) has been a primary candidate for the surrogate model, thanks to its Bayesian-principled uncertainty quantification power and modeling flexibility. However, its challenges have also spurred an array of alternatives whose convergence properties could be more opaque. Motivated by these, we study in this paper an axiomatic framework that elicits the minimal requirements to guarantee black-box optimization convergence that could apply beyond GP-based methods. Moreover, we leverage the design freedom in our framework, which we call Pseudo-Bayesian Optimization, to construct empirically superior algorithms. In particular, we show how using simple local regression, and a suitable randomized prior construction to quantify uncertainty, not only guarantees convergence but also consistently outperforms state-of-the-art benchmarks in examples ranging from high-dimensional synthetic experiments to realistic hyperparameter tuning and robotic applications.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Standard Gaussian Process Can Be Excellent for High-Dimensional Bayesian Optimization
Zhitong Xu, Haitao Wang, Jeff M Phillips, Shandian Zhe
A longstanding belief holds that Bayesian Optimization (BO) with standard Gaussian processes (GP) -- referred to as standard BO -- underperforms in high-dimensional optimization problems. While this belief seems plausible, it lacks both robust empirical evidence and theoretical justification. To address this gap, we present a systematic investigation. First, through a comprehensive evaluation across eleven widely used benchmarks, we found that while the popular Square Exponential (SE) kernel often leads to poor performance, using Matern kernels enables standard BO to consistently achieve top-tier results, frequently surpassing methods specifically designed for high-dimensional optimization. Second, our theoretical analysis reveals that the SE kernels failure primarily stems from improper initialization of the length-scale parameters, which are commonly used in practice but can cause gradient vanishing in training. We provide a probabilistic bound to characterize this issue, showing that Matern kernels are less susceptible and can robustly handle much higher dimensions. Third, we propose a simple robust initialization strategy that dramatically improves the performance of the SE kernel, bringing it close to state of the art methods, without requiring any additional priors or regularization. We prove another probabilistic bound that demonstrates how the gradient vanishing issue can be effectively mitigated with our method. Our findings advocate for a re-evaluation of standard BOs potential in high-dimensional settings.
Read more10/10/2024
🛠️
0
Sample-Efficient Bayesian Optimization with Transfer Learning for Heterogeneous Search Spaces
Aryan Deshwal, Sait Cakmak, Yuhou Xia, David Eriksson
Bayesian optimization (BO) is a powerful approach to sample-efficient optimization of black-box functions. However, in settings with very few function evaluations, a successful application of BO may require transferring information from historical experiments. These related experiments may not have exactly the same tunable parameters (search spaces), motivating the need for BO with transfer learning for heterogeneous search spaces. In this paper, we propose two methods for this setting. The first approach leverages a Gaussian process (GP) model with a conditional kernel to transfer information between different search spaces. Our second approach treats the missing parameters as hyperparameters of the GP model that can be inferred jointly with the other GP hyperparameters or set to fixed values. We show that these two methods perform well on several benchmark problems.
Read more9/10/2024