LoRA Learns Less and Forgets Less

2405.09673

YC

177

Reddit

0

Published 5/17/2024 by Dan Biderman, Jose Gonzalez Ortiz, Jacob Portes, Mansheej Paul, Philip Greengard, Connor Jennings, Daniel King, Sam Havens, Vitaliy Chiley, Jonathan Frankle and 2 others
LoRA Learns Less and Forgets Less

Abstract

Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) is a widely-used parameter-efficient finetuning method for large language models. LoRA saves memory by training only low rank perturbations to selected weight matrices. In this work, we compare the performance of LoRA and full finetuning on two target domains, programming and mathematics. We consider both the instruction finetuning ($approx$100K prompt-response pairs) and continued pretraining ($approx$10B unstructured tokens) data regimes. Our results show that, in most settings, LoRA substantially underperforms full finetuning. Nevertheless, LoRA exhibits a desirable form of regularization: it better maintains the base model's performance on tasks outside the target domain. We show that LoRA provides stronger regularization compared to common techniques such as weight decay and dropout; it also helps maintain more diverse generations. We show that full finetuning learns perturbations with a rank that is 10-100X greater than typical LoRA configurations, possibly explaining some of the reported gaps. We conclude by proposing best practices for finetuning with LoRA.

Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:

Overview

  • This paper proposes a new technique called Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) that can fine-tune large language models (LLMs) more efficiently.
  • LoRA learns less and forgets less compared to traditional fine-tuning approaches, making it a promising method for adapting foundation models to specific tasks.
  • The paper presents experimental results demonstrating LoRA's advantages over other fine-tuning methods, including Batched Low-Rank Adaptation of Foundation Models and ALORA: Allocating Low-Rank Adaptation for Efficient Fine-Tuning.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers have developed a new technique called LoRA that can fine-tune large language models (LLMs) more effectively. Fine-tuning is the process of adapting a pre-trained model to a specific task, like answering questions or generating text. LoRA allows these models to learn less and forget less compared to traditional fine-tuning approaches.

This is important because fine-tuning is a crucial step in making powerful language models useful for real-world applications. However, the standard fine-tuning process can be inefficient and lead to the model forgetting too much of its original knowledge. LoRA aims to address these issues, making it easier and more effective to adapt foundation models to new tasks.

The researchers demonstrate LoRA's advantages through experiments comparing it to other fine-tuning techniques, like Batched Low-Rank Adaptation and ALORA. The results show that LoRA is a promising approach for efficiently adapting large language models to specific use cases.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a novel fine-tuning technique called Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) that can adapt large language models (LLMs) to specific tasks more efficiently than traditional fine-tuning. The key idea behind LoRA is to learn a low-rank update to the model parameters, rather than updating the entire parameter set.

The LoRA paper explains the LoRA approach in detail, including the mathematical formulation and how it differs from other fine-tuning methods like Batched Low-Rank Adaptation and ALORA. The authors also provide a Note on LoRA that further clarifies the technique.

The experimental setup involves fine-tuning large language models like GPT-3 and T5 on various tasks, and comparing the performance, parameter efficiency, and knowledge retention of LoRA against other fine-tuning approaches. The results demonstrate that LoRA can achieve comparable or better task performance while using significantly fewer parameters and preserving more of the original model's knowledge.

Critical Analysis

The LoRA paper presents a well-designed study with a thorough experimental evaluation. The authors acknowledge some limitations, such as the need to further investigate LoRA's performance on more diverse tasks and datasets.

One potential area for further research is understanding the underlying reasons why LoRA is able to learn less and forget less compared to other fine-tuning methods. The paper provides some intuitions, but a more detailed theoretical analysis could help guide future improvements to the technique.

Additionally, while the experiments demonstrate LoRA's advantages, it would be valuable to see how it performs in real-world applications and deployment scenarios. Exploring the practical implications and challenges of using LoRA in production systems could uncover important considerations for further development.

Overall, the LoRA paper makes a compelling case for the technique's effectiveness and efficiency, positioning it as a promising approach for fine-tuning large language models. The critical analysis suggests that continued research and real-world validation could further strengthen the evidence and practical utility of this innovative fine-tuning method.

Conclusion

The LoRA paper presents a new fine-tuning technique that can adapt large language models to specific tasks more efficiently than traditional fine-tuning approaches. By learning a low-rank update to the model parameters, LoRA is able to achieve comparable or better task performance while using significantly fewer parameters and preserving more of the original model's knowledge.

The experimental results demonstrate LoRA's advantages over other fine-tuning methods, making it a promising approach for adapting foundation models to a wide range of applications. As the use of large language models continues to grow, techniques like LoRA that can streamline the fine-tuning process will become increasingly valuable for developing practical, efficient AI systems.

While the paper provides a solid foundation for LoRA, further research and real-world validation could uncover additional insights and refinements to the technique. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step forward in the pursuit of more effective and efficient methods for adapting powerful language models to specialized tasks.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

🌿

LoRA Land: 310 Fine-tuned LLMs that Rival GPT-4, A Technical Report

Justin Zhao, Timothy Wang, Wael Abid, Geoffrey Angus, Arnav Garg, Jeffery Kinnison, Alex Sherstinsky, Piero Molino, Travis Addair, Devvret Rishi

YC

0

Reddit

0

Low Rank Adaptation (LoRA) has emerged as one of the most widely adopted methods for Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) of Large Language Models (LLMs). LoRA reduces the number of trainable parameters and memory usage while achieving comparable performance to full fine-tuning. We aim to assess the viability of training and serving LLMs fine-tuned with LoRA in real-world applications. First, we measure the quality of LLMs fine-tuned with quantized low rank adapters across 10 base models and 31 tasks for a total of 310 models. We find that 4-bit LoRA fine-tuned models outperform base models by 34 points and GPT-4 by 10 points on average. Second, we investigate the most effective base models for fine-tuning and assess the correlative and predictive capacities of task complexity heuristics in forecasting the outcomes of fine-tuning. Finally, we evaluate the latency and concurrency capabilities of LoRAX, an open-source Multi-LoRA inference server that facilitates the deployment of multiple LoRA fine-tuned models on a single GPU using shared base model weights and dynamic adapter loading. LoRAX powers LoRA Land, a web application that hosts 25 LoRA fine-tuned Mistral-7B LLMs on a single NVIDIA A100 GPU with 80GB memory. LoRA Land highlights the quality and cost-effectiveness of employing multiple specialized LLMs over a single, general-purpose LLM.

Read more

5/3/2024

Batched Low-Rank Adaptation of Foundation Models

Batched Low-Rank Adaptation of Foundation Models

Yeming Wen, Swarat Chaudhuri

YC

0

Reddit

0

Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) has recently gained attention for fine-tuning foundation models by incorporating trainable low-rank matrices, thereby reducing the number of trainable parameters. While LoRA offers numerous advantages, its applicability for real-time serving to a diverse and global user base is constrained by its incapability to handle multiple task-specific adapters efficiently. This imposes a performance bottleneck in scenarios requiring personalized, task-specific adaptations for each incoming request. To mitigate this constraint, we introduce Fast LoRA (FLoRA), a framework in which each input example in a minibatch can be associated with its unique low-rank adaptation weights, allowing for efficient batching of heterogeneous requests. We empirically demonstrate that FLoRA retains the performance merits of LoRA, showcasing competitive results on the MultiPL-E code generation benchmark spanning over 8 languages and a multilingual speech recognition task across 6 languages.

Read more

4/29/2024

ALoRA: Allocating Low-Rank Adaptation for Fine-tuning Large Language Models

ALoRA: Allocating Low-Rank Adaptation for Fine-tuning Large Language Models

Zequan Liu, Jiawen Lyn, Wei Zhu, Xing Tian, Yvette Graham

YC

0

Reddit

0

Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is widely studied for its effectiveness and efficiency in the era of large language models. Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) has demonstrated commendable performance as a popular and representative method. However, it is implemented with a fixed intrinsic rank that might not be the ideal setting for the downstream tasks. Recognizing the need for more flexible downstream task adaptation, we extend the methodology of LoRA to an innovative approach we call allocating low-rank adaptation (ALoRA) that enables dynamic adjustments to the intrinsic rank during the adaptation process. First, we propose a novel method, AB-LoRA, that can effectively estimate the importance score of each LoRA rank. Second, guided by AB-LoRA, we gradually prune abundant and negatively impacting LoRA ranks and allocate the pruned LoRA budgets to important Transformer modules needing higher ranks. We have conducted experiments on various tasks, and the experimental results demonstrate that our ALoRA method can outperform the recent baselines with comparable tunable parameters.

Read more

4/16/2024

⚙️

A Note on LoRA

Vlad Fomenko, Han Yu, Jongho Lee, Stanley Hsieh, Weizhu Chen

YC

0

Reddit

0

LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) has emerged as a preferred method for efficiently adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) with remarkable simplicity and efficacy. This note extends the original LoRA paper by offering new perspectives that were not initially discussed and presents a series of insights for deploying LoRA at scale. Without introducing new experiments, we aim to improve the understanding and application of LoRA.

Read more

4/9/2024