Knowledge Editing for Large Language Models: A Survey

    Read original: arXiv:2310.16218 - Published 9/23/2024 by Song Wang, Yaochen Zhu, Haochen Liu, Zaiyi Zheng, Chen Chen, Jundong Li
    Total Score

    1

    💬

    Sign in to get full access

    or

    If you already have an account, we'll log you in

    Overview

    • Large language models (LLMs) have transformed academia and industry with their ability to understand, analyze, and generate text.
    • However, LLMs are computationally expensive to pre-train due to their massive parameters.
    • Updating pre-trained LLMs with new knowledge is also challenging and can degrade existing knowledge.
    • Knowledge-based Model Editing (KME) aims to precisely modify LLMs to incorporate specific knowledge without negatively impacting other knowledge.

    Plain English Explanation

    Large language models (LLMs) are AI systems that can process and generate human-like text. They have become incredibly powerful and useful in fields like natural language processing, content creation, and language understanding. However, training these models from scratch requires immense computational resources and can be very costly.

    When new information or knowledge needs to be added to an existing LLM, the traditional approach of "fine-tuning" the entire model can be inefficient and may cause the model to lose valuable pre-existing knowledge that is unrelated to the new information.

    Knowledge-based Model Editing (KME) is a newer technique that aims to update LLMs in a more targeted and efficient way. The goal of KME is to modify the LLM to incorporate specific new knowledge without negatively impacting the model's existing knowledge and capabilities. This could allow LLMs to be easily updated with new information over time, making them more flexible and adaptable.

    The key idea behind KME is to find ways to surgically edit the LLM's internal parameters and structure to insert new knowledge, rather than retraining the entire model. This requires developing innovative techniques and strategies to precisely control how the LLM is updated.

    Technical Explanation

    This paper provides a comprehensive survey of the recent advancements in Knowledge-based Model Editing (KME) for large language models (LLMs).

    The authors first introduce a general formulation to encompass different KME strategies. They then propose an innovative taxonomy to categorize existing KME techniques based on how the new knowledge is introduced into the pre-trained LLM.

    The paper investigates various KME strategies, analyzing the key insights, advantages, and limitations of methods from each category. These categories include:

    • Direct Fine-tuning: Retraining the entire LLM on the new knowledge, which can be computationally intensive and risk degrading existing knowledge.
    • Prompt-based Editing: Modifying the input prompts to the LLM to induce the desired knowledge updates.
    • Parameter-based Editing: Directly updating the LLM's internal parameters to incorporate new knowledge.

    Additionally, the authors discuss representative metrics, datasets, and real-world applications of KME.

    Finally, the paper provides an in-depth analysis of the practicality and remaining challenges in this field. The authors suggest promising research directions to further advance KME and enable more efficient and effective updates to large language models.

    Critical Analysis

    The survey paper provides a thorough and well-structured overview of the emerging field of Knowledge-based Model Editing (KME) for large language models (LLMs). The authors' innovative taxonomy of KME strategies is a valuable contribution, as it helps organize and understand the diverse range of techniques being developed in this area.

    One potential limitation highlighted in the paper is the need for more comprehensive evaluation metrics and benchmark datasets to assess the performance of different KME methods. The authors note that existing metrics may not fully capture the nuances of how new knowledge is incorporated without degrading pre-existing capabilities.

    Additionally, the paper acknowledges that many KME techniques are still in the early research stage, and there are significant practical challenges to overcome before they can be widely adopted. For example, the computational and memory requirements of some KME methods may limit their scalability to large, complex LLMs.

    The authors also suggest that further research is needed to better understand the interplay between different types of knowledge and how they can be selectively updated or retained within LLMs. Developing a more fundamental understanding of knowledge representation and reasoning in LLMs could enable more principled and effective KME strategies.

    Overall, this survey paper provides a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners interested in advancing the field of KME. By highlighting the key insights, challenges, and future directions, it can help guide the development of more efficient and effective techniques for updating and enhancing the capabilities of large language models.

    Conclusion

    This comprehensive survey paper has explored the emerging field of Knowledge-based Model Editing (KME) for large language models (LLMs). KME aims to overcome the limitations of traditional fine-tuning methods, which can be computationally expensive and risk degrading existing knowledge in LLMs.

    The authors have presented a general formulation of KME and an innovative taxonomy to categorize the various strategies being developed, including direct fine-tuning, prompt-based editing, and parameter-based editing. By analyzing the key insights, advantages, and limitations of methods from each category, the paper provides valuable insights for researchers and practitioners working on this problem.

    The critical analysis section highlights the need for more robust evaluation metrics and benchmark datasets, as well as the practical challenges of scaling KME techniques to large, complex LLMs. However, the authors also suggest promising research directions, such as developing a deeper understanding of knowledge representation and reasoning in LLMs, which could enable more principled and effective KME strategies.

    As the field of AI continues to advance, the ability to efficiently update and enhance large language models will become increasingly important. This survey paper serves as a valuable resource for navigating the current state of KME and charting the future course of this exciting research area.



    This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

    Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

    Related Papers

    💬

    Total Score

    1

    Knowledge Editing for Large Language Models: A Survey

    Song Wang, Yaochen Zhu, Haochen Liu, Zaiyi Zheng, Chen Chen, Jundong Li

    Large language models (LLMs) have recently transformed both the academic and industrial landscapes due to their remarkable capacity to understand, analyze, and generate texts based on their vast knowledge and reasoning ability. Nevertheless, one major drawback of LLMs is their substantial computational cost for pre-training due to their unprecedented amounts of parameters. The disadvantage is exacerbated when new knowledge frequently needs to be introduced into the pre-trained model. Therefore, it is imperative to develop effective and efficient techniques to update pre-trained LLMs. Traditional methods encode new knowledge in pre-trained LLMs through direct fine-tuning. However, naively re-training LLMs can be computationally intensive and risks degenerating valuable pre-trained knowledge irrelevant to the update in the model. Recently, Knowledge-based Model Editing (KME) has attracted increasing attention, which aims to precisely modify the LLMs to incorporate specific knowledge, without negatively influencing other irrelevant knowledge. In this survey, we aim to provide a comprehensive and in-depth overview of recent advances in the field of KME. We first introduce a general formulation of KME to encompass different KME strategies. Afterward, we provide an innovative taxonomy of KME techniques based on how the new knowledge is introduced into pre-trained LLMs, and investigate existing KME strategies while analyzing key insights, advantages, and limitations of methods from each category. Moreover, representative metrics, datasets, and applications of KME are introduced accordingly. Finally, we provide an in-depth analysis regarding the practicality and remaining challenges of KME and suggest promising research directions for further advancement in this field.

    Read more

    9/23/2024

    💬

    Total Score

    0

    New!Editing Conceptual Knowledge for Large Language Models

    Xiaohan Wang, Shengyu Mao, Ningyu Zhang, Shumin Deng, Yunzhi Yao, Yue Shen, Lei Liang, Jinjie Gu, Huajun Chen

    Recently, there has been a growing interest in knowledge editing for Large Language Models (LLMs). Current approaches and evaluations merely explore the instance-level editing, while whether LLMs possess the capability to modify concepts remains unclear. This paper pioneers the investigation of editing conceptual knowledge for LLMs, by constructing a novel benchmark dataset ConceptEdit and establishing a suite of new metrics for evaluation. The experimental results reveal that, although existing editing methods can efficiently modify concept-level definition to some extent, they also have the potential to distort the related instantial knowledge in LLMs, leading to poor performance. We anticipate this can inspire further progress in better understanding LLMs. Our project homepage is available at https://zjunlp.github.io/project/ConceptEdit.

    Read more

    10/8/2024

    Knowledge Mechanisms in Large Language Models: A Survey and Perspective
    Total Score

    0

    Knowledge Mechanisms in Large Language Models: A Survey and Perspective

    Mengru Wang, Yunzhi Yao, Ziwen Xu, Shuofei Qiao, Shumin Deng, Peng Wang, Xiang Chen, Jia-Chen Gu, Yong Jiang, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang

    Understanding knowledge mechanisms in Large Language Models (LLMs) is crucial for advancing towards trustworthy AGI. This paper reviews knowledge mechanism analysis from a novel taxonomy including knowledge utilization and evolution. Knowledge utilization delves into the mechanism of memorization, comprehension and application, and creation. Knowledge evolution focuses on the dynamic progression of knowledge within individual and group LLMs. Moreover, we discuss what knowledge LLMs have learned, the reasons for the fragility of parametric knowledge, and the potential dark knowledge (hypothesis) that will be challenging to address. We hope this work can help understand knowledge in LLMs and provide insights for future research.

    Read more

    10/8/2024

    Time Sensitive Knowledge Editing through Efficient Finetuning
    Total Score

    0

    Time Sensitive Knowledge Editing through Efficient Finetuning

    Xiou Ge, Ali Mousavi, Edouard Grave, Armand Joulin, Kun Qian, Benjamin Han, Mostafa Arefiyan, Yunyao Li

    Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capability in different tasks and are bringing transformative changes to many domains. However, keeping the knowledge in LLMs up-to-date remains a challenge once pretraining is complete. It is thus essential to design effective methods to both update obsolete knowledge and induce new knowledge into LLMs. Existing locate-and-edit knowledge editing (KE) method suffers from two limitations. First, the post-edit LLMs by such methods generally have poor capability in answering complex queries that require multi-hop reasoning. Second, the long run-time of such locate-and-edit methods to perform knowledge edits make it infeasible for large scale KE in practice. In this paper, we explore Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques as an alternative for KE. We curate a more comprehensive temporal KE dataset with both knowledge update and knowledge injection examples for KE performance benchmarking. We further probe the effect of fine-tuning on a range of layers in an LLM for the multi-hop QA task. We find that PEFT performs better than locate-and-edit techniques for time-sensitive knowledge edits.

    Read more

    7/24/2024