Iterated Learning Improves Compositionality in Large Vision-Language Models

2404.02145

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/3/2024 by Chenhao Zheng, Jieyu Zhang, Aniruddha Kembhavi, Ranjay Krishna
Iterated Learning Improves Compositionality in Large Vision-Language Models

Abstract

A fundamental characteristic common to both human vision and natural language is their compositional nature. Yet, despite the performance gains contributed by large vision and language pretraining, recent investigations find that most-if not all-our state-of-the-art vision-language models struggle at compositionality. They are unable to distinguish between images of a girl in white facing a man in black and a girl in black facing a man in white. Moreover, prior work suggests that compositionality doesn't arise with scale: larger model sizes or training data don't help. This paper develops a new iterated training algorithm that incentivizes compositionality. We draw on decades of cognitive science research that identifies cultural transmission-the need to teach a new generation-as a necessary inductive prior that incentivizes humans to develop compositional languages. Specifically, we reframe vision-language contrastive learning as the Lewis Signaling Game between a vision agent and a language agent, and operationalize cultural transmission by iteratively resetting one of the agent's weights during training. After every iteration, this training paradigm induces representations that become easier to learn, a property of compositional languages: e.g. our model trained on CC3M and CC12M improves standard CLIP by 4.7%, 4.0% respectfully in the SugarCrepe benchmark.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores how "iterated learning" can improve the compositional abilities of large vision-language models.
  • Iterated learning involves training models using data generated by other models, rather than human-created data.
  • The authors find that this approach enhances the models' ability to combine visual and linguistic concepts in novel ways.
  • This has implications for building more flexible and versatile AI systems that can better understand and generate complex, compositional language.

Plain English Explanation

Large vision-language models are AI systems that can understand and generate human language while also analyzing visual information. However, these models often struggle with compositionality - the ability to flexibly combine basic concepts into novel, more complex expressions.

The researchers in this paper propose a new training approach called "iterated learning" to address this challenge. Instead of training the models solely on human-created data, they have the models learn from data generated by other models. This iterative process allows the models to develop richer internal representations and more flexible reasoning capabilities.

Imagine you're trying to learn a new language. The traditional approach would be to study vocabulary and grammar rules from textbooks and conversations with native speakers. But an iterated learning approach would involve you teaching what you've learned to a language learner bot, then having that bot teach you back what it's learned. This back-and-forth process could help you gain a deeper, more nuanced understanding of the language.

Similarly, the iterated learning technique helps vision-language models go beyond simply memorizing associations between words and visual concepts. Instead, the models learn to dynamically combine these building blocks in novel ways, showing more human-like compositionality and creativity.

Technical Explanation

The key technical contributions of this paper are:

  1. Iterated Learning Procedure: The authors develop an iterated learning framework where a "student" model is trained on data generated by a "teacher" model. This process is repeated over multiple iterations, allowing the student model to gradually develop more sophisticated language and reasoning abilities.

  2. Compositional Evaluation: To assess the models' compositional skills, the authors design a suite of novel evaluation tasks that test the models' ability to understand and generate complex, compositional expressions involving visual and linguistic concepts.

  3. Architectural Insights: The authors analyze the internal representations of the iterated learning models and find that this approach encourages the development of more disentangled and modular representations, which facilitates compositional reasoning.

Through extensive experiments, the authors demonstrate that the iterated learning approach significantly boosts the compositional performance of large vision-language models compared to standard training techniques. This suggests iterated learning could be a valuable tool for building more flexible and versatile AI systems.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thoughtful and rigorous exploration of iterated learning for improving compositional abilities in vision-language models. However, a few caveats and areas for further research are worth noting:

  1. Scalability: While effective on the benchmarks tested, it's unclear how well the iterated learning approach would scale to larger, more complex model architectures and datasets. The computational overhead of the iterative training process may become prohibitive.

  2. Real-World Applicability: The evaluation tasks, while designed to test compositional skills, may not fully capture the nuances of how these models would perform in real-world language understanding and generation scenarios. Further research is needed to understand the practical implications.

  3. Human-Centricity: The paper focuses on improving the compositional abilities of AI models, but does not explore how this might impact the human experience of interacting with such systems. Potential issues around transparency, trust, and mental models should be considered.

Overall, this paper represents an important step forward in addressing the compositionality challenge for large vision-language models. The iterated learning approach is a promising technique that warrants further investigation and refinement.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that the iterated learning framework can significantly enhance the compositional abilities of large-scale vision-language models. By having models learn from other models, rather than just human-created data, they develop more flexible and generative language understanding and generation capabilities.

While further work is needed to address scalability and real-world applicability, this work represents an important advance in the quest to build AI systems that can engage in more human-like, creative language use. As these models continue to improve, they may enable more natural and intuitive interactions between humans and machines, with profound implications for how we work, learn, and communicate in the future.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Exploring the Spectrum of Visio-Linguistic Compositionality and Recognition

Exploring the Spectrum of Visio-Linguistic Compositionality and Recognition

Youngtaek Oh, Pyunghwan Ahn, Jinhyung Kim, Gwangmo Song, Soonyoung Lee, In So Kweon, Junmo Kim

YC

0

Reddit

0

Vision and language models (VLMs) such as CLIP have showcased remarkable zero-shot recognition abilities yet face challenges in visio-linguistic compositionality, particularly in linguistic comprehension and fine-grained image-text alignment. This paper explores the intricate relationship between compositionality and recognition -- two pivotal aspects of VLM capability. We conduct a comprehensive evaluation of existing VLMs, covering both pre-training approaches aimed at recognition and the fine-tuning methods designed to improve compositionality. Our evaluation employs 12 benchmarks for compositionality, along with 21 zero-shot classification and two retrieval benchmarks for recognition. In our analysis from 274 CLIP model checkpoints, we reveal patterns and trade-offs that emerge between compositional understanding and recognition accuracy. Ultimately, this necessitates strategic efforts towards developing models that improve both capabilities, as well as the meticulous formulation of benchmarks for compositionality. We open our evaluation framework at https://github.com/ytaek-oh/vl_compo.

Read more

6/14/2024

Development of Compositionality and Generalization through Interactive Learning of Language and Action of Robots

Development of Compositionality and Generalization through Interactive Learning of Language and Action of Robots

Prasanna Vijayaraghavan, Jeffrey Frederic Queisser, Sergio Verduzco Flores, Jun Tani

YC

0

Reddit

0

Humans excel at applying learned behavior to unlearned situations. A crucial component of this generalization behavior is our ability to compose/decompose a whole into reusable parts, an attribute known as compositionality. One of the fundamental questions in robotics concerns this characteristic. How can linguistic compositionality be developed concomitantly with sensorimotor skills through associative learning, particularly when individuals only learn partial linguistic compositions and their corresponding sensorimotor patterns? To address this question, we propose a brain-inspired neural network model that integrates vision, proprioception, and language into a framework of predictive coding and active inference, based on the free-energy principle. The effectiveness and capabilities of this model were assessed through various simulation experiments conducted with a robot arm. Our results show that generalization in learning to unlearned verb-noun compositions, is significantly enhanced when training variations of task composition are increased. We attribute this to self-organized compositional structures in linguistic latent state space being influenced significantly by sensorimotor learning. Ablation studies show that visual attention and working memory are essential to accurately generate visuo-motor sequences to achieve linguistically represented goals. These insights advance our understanding of mechanisms underlying development of compositionality through interactions of linguistic and sensorimotor experience.

Read more

4/1/2024

Contrasting Intra-Modal and Ranking Cross-Modal Hard Negatives to Enhance Visio-Linguistic Compositional Understanding

Contrasting Intra-Modal and Ranking Cross-Modal Hard Negatives to Enhance Visio-Linguistic Compositional Understanding

Le Zhang, Rabiul Awal, Aishwarya Agrawal

YC

0

Reddit

0

Vision-Language Models (VLMs), such as CLIP, exhibit strong image-text comprehension abilities, facilitating advances in several downstream tasks such as zero-shot image classification, image-text retrieval, and text-to-image generation. However, the compositional reasoning abilities of existing VLMs remains subpar. The root of this limitation lies in the inadequate alignment between the images and captions in the pretraining datasets. Additionally, the current contrastive learning objective fails to focus on fine-grained grounding components like relations, actions, and attributes, resulting in bag-of-words representations. We introduce a simple and effective method to improve compositional reasoning in VLMs. Our method better leverages available datasets by refining and expanding the standard image-text contrastive learning framework. Our approach does not require specific annotations and does not incur extra parameters. When integrated with CLIP, our technique yields notable improvement over state-of-the-art baselines across five vision-language compositional benchmarks. We open-source our code at https://github.com/lezhang7/Enhance-FineGrained.

Read more

4/26/2024

Diagnosing the Compositional Knowledge of Vision Language Models from a Game-Theoretic View

Diagnosing the Compositional Knowledge of Vision Language Models from a Game-Theoretic View

Jin Wang, Shichao Dong, Yapeng Zhu, Kelu Yao, Weidong Zhao, Chao Li, Ping Luo

YC

0

Reddit

0

Compositional reasoning capabilities are usually considered as fundamental skills to characterize human perception. Recent studies show that current Vision Language Models (VLMs) surprisingly lack sufficient knowledge with respect to such capabilities. To this end, we propose to thoroughly diagnose the composition representations encoded by VLMs, systematically revealing the potential cause for this weakness. Specifically, we propose evaluation methods from a novel game-theoretic view to assess the vulnerability of VLMs on different aspects of compositional understanding, e.g., relations and attributes. Extensive experimental results demonstrate and validate several insights to understand the incapabilities of VLMs on compositional reasoning, which provide useful and reliable guidance for future studies. The deliverables will be updated at https://vlms-compositionality-gametheory.github.io/.

Read more

5/28/2024