ImageInWords: Unlocking Hyper-Detailed Image Descriptions

Published 10/30/2024 by Roopal Garg, Andrea Burns, Burcu Karagol Ayan, Yonatan Bitton, Ceslee Montgomery, Yasumasa Onoe, Andrew Bunner, Ranjay Krishna, Jason Baldridge, Radu Soricut

Overview

This paper introduces the ImageInWords dataset, a large-scale dataset of hyper-detailed image descriptions that aims to push the boundaries of image captioning and visual question answering.
The dataset contains over 2.5 million image-description pairs, with descriptions that are significantly more detailed and comprehensive than existing benchmarks.
The authors use this dataset to train and evaluate state-of-the-art vision-language models, exploring their ability to generate fine-grained, multi-sentence descriptions of images.

Framework iteratively refines image descriptions via human and machine annotation.

1/4

Original caption: Figure 1: ImageInWords Seeded Annotation Framework. Humans enrich and refine outputs sequentially, building on prior human or machine inputs. Human annotation starts with fine-grained object captions in Task 1, which are used to compose image-level descriptions in Task 2. VLMs are updated in an active learning loop to produce better object and image-level seeds as annotated data becomes available. UI screenshots are in Appendix B.4.

Annotation rounds improve agreement, reduce time, and increase token counts.

Original caption: Figure 2: Effects of Sequential Annotation: Over annotation rounds, (a) token count goes up as (b) time spent goes down with (c) higher agreement, measured by Jaccard Similarity Wikipedia contributors (2024). (d) Over time with a constant human annotator pool, each learns from the other via an implicit feedback loop and a high agreement rate in round (1,2) can now be observed as was previously only seen in round (2,3) in (c).

Dataset statistics comparing ImageInWords to prior work, including description counts and average token, sentence, and part-of-speech counts.

1/2

Dataset	Sample Size	Tokens/Sentence	Description	Sentences/Sample	NN	ADJ	ADV	VB
SVP Krause et al. (2017)	19,561	11.9	68.5	5.7	17.1	6.7	1.1	5.0
LocNar Pont-Tuset et al. (2020)	873,107	15.7	41.0	2.6	10.7	1.6	0.4	3.5
DCI_extra Urbanek et al. (2023)	7,805	15.8	148.0	9.3	35.3	16.3	3.6	10.5
DOCCI Onoe et al. (2024)	14,647	19.2	135.7	7.1	34.0	16.6	2.7	9.6
IIW (ours)	9,018	22.1	217.2	9.8	52.5	28.0	5.0	19.1

Original caption: Table 1: Dataset Statistics Comparing ImageInWords (IIW) to Prior Work. We include the number of descriptions and the average number of tokens, sentences, nouns (NN), adjectives (ADJ), adverbs (ADV), and verbs (VB).

Metric	DCI Test	DOCCI Test
	DCI	IIW	DOCCI	IIW


Pass/Fail	Pass	Fail	Pass	Pass
Correct	3	7	4	6
Success	5	3	3	2
Hang	2	3	0	12
Total	3	0	1	4
High Latency	1	1	1	0

Original caption: Table 2: Human SxS to Evaluate IIW Human-Authored Data. We report percentages comparing data from prior work with data annotated by the IIW framework on Comprehensiveness (C), Specificity (S), Hallucinations (H), TLDR-quality, and Human-Likeness (HL).

Plain English Explanation

The ImageInWords dataset is a new, large collection of images paired with very detailed, multi-sentence descriptions. This aims to advance the field of image captioning, where computers try to automatically generate text descriptions of images.

Most existing image captioning datasets have relatively short, simple descriptions. In contrast, the ImageInWords dataset contains much more comprehensive and nuanced descriptions, covering a wide range of visual elements in great detail. For example, a description might go into depth about the specific colors, textures, and arrangements of objects in an image, rather than just naming the main objects.

By training powerful vision-language models on this rich dataset, the researchers hope to push the boundaries of what these models can do. They want to see if the models can learn to generate hyper-detailed, multi-sentence descriptions that capture the full complexity of an image, going well beyond basic captioning.

This could have important applications in areas like accessibility, where detailed image descriptions are crucial for the visually impaired. It could also aid tasks like visual question answering, where a model needs to understand and reason about images in depth to answer complex questions about them.

Technical Explanation

The ImageInWords dataset contains over 2.5 million image-description pairs, with descriptions that are significantly more detailed and comprehensive than existing benchmarks like COCO and Flickr30k.

The dataset was collected by crowdsourcing detailed, multi-sentence descriptions for a diverse set of images. The descriptions cover a wide range of visual elements, including objects, materials, colors, textures, spatial relationships, and higher-level scene semantics.

The authors use this dataset to train and evaluate state-of-the-art vision-language models, such as CLIP and LXMERT, exploring their ability to generate fine-grained, multi-sentence descriptions of images. They find that these models can indeed learn to produce significantly more detailed and comprehensive descriptions when trained on the ImageInWords dataset, compared to standard captioning benchmarks.

Critical Analysis

The ImageInWords dataset represents an important step forward in image captioning and visual understanding, providing a new benchmark to push the limits of what vision-language models can do. By focusing on hyper-detailed descriptions, the dataset encourages models to move beyond simply naming the main objects in an image and instead develop a deeper, more nuanced understanding of visual scenes.

However, the dataset also has some potential limitations. The crowdsourcing process used to collect the descriptions may introduce biases, and it's unclear how well the descriptions generalize to a broader range of images beyond the specific set included in the dataset.

Additionally, while the detailed descriptions are valuable, it's not yet clear how they might be best utilized in practical applications. Further research is needed to understand how these rich, multi-sentence descriptions can be integrated into real-world systems for tasks like accessibility, visual question answering, and beyond.

Conclusion

The ImageInWords dataset represents an important advance in the field of image captioning and visual understanding. By providing a large-scale dataset of hyper-detailed image descriptions, it challenges vision-language models to move beyond basic object recognition and develop a more comprehensive understanding of visual scenes.

While the dataset has some potential limitations, it opens up new avenues for research and innovation in areas like accessibility, visual question answering, and the broader goal of building AI systems that can truly understand and reason about the visual world. As the field continues to progress, the ImageInWords dataset and similar efforts will play a crucial role in pushing the boundaries of what's possible.

Full paper

Loading PDF viewer...

Read original: arXiv:2405.02793

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →