# Harvesting Brownian Motion: Zero Energy Computational Sampling

2

🔎

Sign in to get full access

## Overview

- The key limitation in advancing computational power is the high energy consumption of electronic components.
- Reversible computation can potentially overcome the Landauer limit, but it's unclear if this can be achieved without energy dissipation.
- This paper focuses on the simpler context of sampling problems, which avoid modeling the energy costs of changing the machine's input.

## Plain English Explanation

The biggest challenge in making computers more powerful these days is not making the individual components smaller or faster, but rather reducing how much energy they use. One potential solution is reversible computation, which could theoretically avoid the minimum energy required for each computation step. However, it's unclear if truly reusable computation without any energy loss is possible.

This paper looks at a simpler problem: generating random samples from a particular distribution, without needing any input data. The goal is to build a device that can continuously generate these samples using only the random motion of atoms and molecules (Brownian motion), with no external energy source. The researchers show that such a device could efficiently execute the algorithm for generating the desired samples, only needing to wait a short time between each new sample.

They consider two ways the device could output the samples: a "Las Vegas" model, where every 4 tries on average produces a perfect sample, or a "Monte Carlo" model, where each try gives an approximate sample but they are all usable. The underlying model is based on random walks through the possible states of a general computational machine, like a Turing machine.

Understanding how to sample complex probability distributions with no energy use could provide insights into the fundamental energy requirements of computation. This might lead to more energy-efficient randomized algorithms in the future.

## Technical Explanation

The paper explores the problem of generating samples from a probability distribution using only the random thermal motion of a physical system, without any external energy input. This is motivated by the fact that the key limitation on advancing computational power is now the high energy consumption of electronic components, rather than just manufacturing density and speed.

The researchers base their model on continuous-time random walks over the state space graph of a general computational machine, using a space-bounded Turing machine as a specific example. They consider two output models: a "Las Vegas" model where the device samples from the exact target distribution every 4 tries on average, and a "Monte Carlo" model where each try succeeds but the distribution is only approximated.

The key result is that such a device can efficiently execute the sampling algorithm $A$, only needing to wait $O(\text{time}(A)^2)$ between samples. This is an important finding, as it suggests that computationally complex probability distributions could be sampled perpetually using only thermal fluctuations, without any energy dissipation.

The problem of sampling without energy use informs our understanding of the fundamental energy requirements of computation, and could lead to more energy-efficient randomized algorithms in the future, such as those used in combinatorial optimization.

## Critical Analysis

The paper presents an interesting theoretical framework for perpetually generating samples from a probability distribution using only thermal fluctuations, without any external energy input. This is an important problem to consider, as reducing the energy consumption of computation is a key challenge facing the field.

One potential limitation of the approach is that it relies on a highly idealized model of a computational device and its interactions with the thermal environment. In practice, there may be significant challenges in building a physical system that can reliably implement the random walk dynamics described in the paper, especially for more complex probability distributions.

Additionally, the paper focuses solely on the sampling problem, and does not address the energy costs associated with setting up the initial state of the computational device or extracting useful information from the samples. These factors could significantly impact the overall energy efficiency of the approach in real-world applications.

Further research is needed to better understand the practical feasibility and limitations of this approach, as well as to explore how the insights from this work could be applied to develop more energy-efficient randomized algorithms and computational systems.

## Conclusion

This paper presents a theoretical framework for generating samples from a probability distribution using only the thermal motion of a physical system, without any external energy input. The key result is that such a device can efficiently execute the sampling algorithm, only needing to wait a short time between each new sample.

Understanding the energy requirements of computationally complex sampling problems can provide insights into the fundamental limits of energy-efficient computation. This research could potentially lead to the development of more energy-efficient randomized algorithms and computational systems in the future, with applications in areas like combinatorial optimization.

While the theoretical model is interesting, further work is needed to assess the practical feasibility and limitations of this approach. Nonetheless, this paper represents an important contribution to the ongoing efforts to reduce the energy consumption of computation and advance the field of energy-efficient computing.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

## Related Papers

🔎

2

### Harvesting Brownian Motion: Zero Energy Computational Sampling

David Doty, Niels Kornerup, Austin Luchsinger, Leo Orshansky, David Soloveichik, Damien Woods

The key factor currently limiting the advancement of computational power of electronic computation is no longer the manufacturing density and speed of components, but rather their high energy consumption. While it has been widely argued that reversible computation can escape the fundamental Landauer limit of $k_B Tln(2)$ Joules per irreversible computational step, there is disagreement around whether indefinitely reusable computation can be achieved without energy dissipation. Here we focus on the relatively simpler context of sampling problems, which take no input, so avoids modeling the energy costs of the observer perturbing the machine to change its input. Given an algorithm $A$ for generating samples from a distribution, we desire a device that can perpetually generate samples from that distribution driven entirely by Brownian motion. We show that such a device can efficiently execute algorithm $A$ in the sense that we must wait only $O(text{time}(A)^2)$ between samples. We consider two output models: Las Vegas, which samples from the exact probability distribution every $4$ tries in expectation, and Monte Carlo, in which every try succeeds but the distribution is only approximated. We base our model on continuous-time random walks over the state space graph of a general computational machine, with a space-bounded Turing machine as one instantiation. The problem of sampling a computationally complex probability distribution with no energy dissipation informs our understanding of the energy requirements of computation, and may lead to more energy efficient randomized algorithms.

Read more8/30/2024

🎲

0

### Estimating truncation effects of quantum bosonic systems using sampling algorithms

Masanori Hanada, Junyu Liu, Enrico Rinaldi, Masaki Tezuka

To simulate bosons on a qubit- or qudit-based quantum computer, one has to regularize the theory by truncating infinite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces to finite dimensions. In the search for practical quantum applications, it is important to know how big the truncation errors can be. In general, it is not easy to estimate errors unless we have a good quantum computer. In this paper, we show that traditional sampling methods on classical devices, specifically Markov Chain Monte Carlo, can address this issue for a rather generic class of bosonic systems with a reasonable amount of computational resources available today. As a demonstration, we apply this idea to the scalar field theory on a two-dimensional lattice, with a size that goes beyond what is achievable using exact diagonalization methods. This method can be used to estimate the resources needed for realistic quantum simulations of bosonic theories, and also, to check the validity of the results of the corresponding quantum simulations.

Read more4/3/2024

0

### Is stochastic thermodynamics the key to understanding the energy costs of computation?

David Wolpert, Jan Korbel, Christopher Lynn, Farita Tasnim, Joshua Grochow, Gulce Kardec{s}, James Aimone, Vijay Balasubramanian, Eric de Giuli, David Doty, Nahuel Freitas, Matteo Marsili, Thomas E. Ouldridge, Andrea Richa, Paul Riechers, 'Edgar Rold'an, Brenda Rubenstein, Zoltan Toroczkai, Joseph Paradiso

The relationship between the thermodynamic and computational characteristics of dynamical physical systems has been a major theoretical interest since at least the 19th century, and has been of increasing practical importance as the energetic cost of digital devices has exploded over the last half century. One of the most important thermodynamic features of real-world computers is that they operate very far from thermal equilibrium, in finite time, with many quickly (co-)evolving degrees of freedom. Such computers also must almost always obey multiple physical constraints on how they work. For example, all modern digital computers are periodic processes, governed by a global clock. Another example is that many computers are modular, hierarchical systems, with strong restrictions on the connectivity of their subsystems. This properties hold both for naturally occurring computers, like brains or Eukaryotic cells, as well as digital systems. These features of real-world computers are absent in 20th century analyses of the thermodynamics of computational processes, which focused on quasi-statically slow processes. However, the field of stochastic thermodynamics has been developed in the last few decades - and it provides the formal tools for analyzing systems that have exactly these features of real-world computers. We argue here that these tools, together with other tools currently being developed in stochastic thermodynamics, may help us understand at a far deeper level just how the fundamental physical properties of dynamic systems are related to the computation that they perform.

Read more8/30/2024

0

### Efficient and Unbiased Sampling of Boltzmann Distributions via Consistency Models

Fengzhe Zhang, Jiajun He, Laurence I. Midgley, Javier Antor'an, Jos'e Miguel Hern'andez-Lobato

Diffusion models have shown promising potential for advancing Boltzmann Generators. However, two critical challenges persist: (1) inherent errors in samples due to model imperfections, and (2) the requirement of hundreds of functional evaluations (NFEs) to achieve high-quality samples. While existing solutions like importance sampling and distillation address these issues separately, they are often incompatible, as most distillation models lack the necessary density information for importance sampling. This paper introduces a novel sampling method that effectively combines Consistency Models (CMs) with importance sampling. We evaluate our approach on both synthetic energy functions and equivariant n-body particle systems. Our method produces unbiased samples using only 6-25 NFEs while achieving a comparable Effective Sample Size (ESS) to Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs) that require approximately 100 NFEs.

Read more9/12/2024