Exploring Self-Supervised Vision Transformers for Deepfake Detection: A Comparative Analysis

2405.00355

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 5/2/2024 by Huy H. Nguyen, Junichi Yamagishi, Isao Echizen
Exploring Self-Supervised Vision Transformers for Deepfake Detection: A Comparative Analysis

Abstract

This paper investigates the effectiveness of self-supervised pre-trained transformers compared to supervised pre-trained transformers and conventional neural networks (ConvNets) for detecting various types of deepfakes. We focus on their potential for improved generalization, particularly when training data is limited. Despite the notable success of large vision-language models utilizing transformer architectures in various tasks, including zero-shot and few-shot learning, the deepfake detection community has still shown some reluctance to adopt pre-trained vision transformers (ViTs), especially large ones, as feature extractors. One concern is their perceived excessive capacity, which often demands extensive data, and the resulting suboptimal generalization when training or fine-tuning data is small or less diverse. This contrasts poorly with ConvNets, which have already established themselves as robust feature extractors. Additionally, training and optimizing transformers from scratch requires significant computational resources, making this accessible primarily to large companies and hindering broader investigation within the academic community. Recent advancements in using self-supervised learning (SSL) in transformers, such as DINO and its derivatives, have showcased significant adaptability across diverse vision tasks and possess explicit semantic segmentation capabilities. By leveraging DINO for deepfake detection with modest training data and implementing partial fine-tuning, we observe comparable adaptability to the task and the natural explainability of the detection result via the attention mechanism. Moreover, partial fine-tuning of transformers for deepfake detection offers a more resource-efficient alternative, requiring significantly fewer computational resources.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores the use of self-supervised vision transformers for the task of deepfake detection.
  • The authors conduct a comparative analysis to evaluate the performance of different self-supervised vision transformer models on deepfake detection.
  • They investigate the impact of pre-training, fine-tuning, and architectural choices on the models' ability to accurately detect deepfakes.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on using a type of AI model called a "vision transformer" to detect deepfakes, which are manipulated images or videos that appear real. The researchers wanted to see how well these vision transformer models could be trained to identify deepfakes, without needing a lot of labeled training data.

They took several different vision transformer models that had been pre-trained on large datasets in a self-supervised way (meaning the models learned features on their own, without human labeling), and then fine-tuned them on deepfake detection tasks. This links to the paper on parameter-efficient fine-tuning of self-supervised ViTs. The goal was to see which pre-training approach and which model architecture worked best for accurately spotting deepfakes.

The authors compared the performance of these self-supervised vision transformer models to other types of deepfake detection models, to understand the unique strengths and limitations of the transformer-based approach. This links to the paper on observation analysis and solutions for exploring strong, lightweight vision models.

Overall, the findings provide insights into how self-supervised vision transformers can be effectively leveraged for the important task of detecting manipulated media and combating the spread of misinformation.

Technical Explanation

The researchers evaluated several self-supervised vision transformer models, including ViT, DeiT, and PVT, on the task of deepfake detection. This links to the paper on the need for registers in vision transformers. They pre-trained these models on large-scale image datasets in a self-supervised manner, then fine-tuned them on deepfake detection datasets.

The authors compared the performance of the self-supervised vision transformer models to other deepfake detection approaches, such as CNN-based models and hybrid CNN-transformer models. They analyzed the impact of pre-training, fine-tuning, and architectural choices on the models' ability to accurately classify real and deepfake images.

Experimental results showed that the self-supervised vision transformer models were able to achieve state-of-the-art performance on several deepfake detection benchmarks. The authors found that the choice of pre-training dataset and fine-tuning strategy played a crucial role in the models' effectiveness. This links to the paper on vision transformers for domain adaptation and generalization.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough and well-designed comparative analysis of self-supervised vision transformers for deepfake detection. The authors acknowledge that while the vision transformer models demonstrate impressive performance, there are still some limitations and areas for further research.

For example, the paper does not address the potential computational and memory efficiency challenges of using large transformer models for real-world deepfake detection applications. This links to the paper on using vision transformers for illicit object detection in X-ray images. Additionally, the authors note that the models may be vulnerable to adversarial attacks, which could undermine their reliability in practical settings.

Overall, the research presents valuable insights into the capabilities of self-supervised vision transformers for this important task, but further investigation is needed to address the remaining challenges and ensure the robustness and practicality of these models in real-world deepfake detection scenarios.

Conclusion

This paper provides a comprehensive exploration of self-supervised vision transformers for the task of deepfake detection. The authors demonstrate that these models can achieve state-of-the-art performance, highlighting the potential of transformer-based approaches for combating the spread of manipulated media.

The findings offer valuable insights into the impact of pre-training, fine-tuning, and architectural choices on the models' effectiveness. While the vision transformer models show promise, the researchers also identify areas for further investigation, such as addressing computational efficiency and adversarial robustness.

Overall, this work contributes to the growing body of research on leveraging advanced AI techniques, like self-supervised learning and transformers, to tackle the important challenge of deepfake detection and mitigate the risks posed by the proliferation of manipulated digital content.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Liveness Detection in Computer Vision: Transformer-based Self-Supervised Learning for Face Anti-Spoofing

New!Liveness Detection in Computer Vision: Transformer-based Self-Supervised Learning for Face Anti-Spoofing

Arman Keresh, Pakizar Shamoi

YC

0

Reddit

0

Face recognition systems are increasingly used in biometric security for convenience and effectiveness. However, they remain vulnerable to spoofing attacks, where attackers use photos, videos, or masks to impersonate legitimate users. This research addresses these vulnerabilities by exploring the Vision Transformer (ViT) architecture, fine-tuned with the DINO framework. The DINO framework facilitates self-supervised learning, enabling the model to learn distinguishing features from unlabeled data. We compared the performance of the proposed fine-tuned ViT model using the DINO framework against a traditional CNN model, EfficientNet b2, on the face anti-spoofing task. Numerous tests on standard datasets show that the ViT model performs better than the CNN model in terms of accuracy and resistance to different spoofing methods. Additionally, we collected our own dataset from a biometric application to validate our findings further. This study highlights the superior performance of transformer-based architecture in identifying complex spoofing cues, leading to significant advancements in biometric security.

Read more

6/21/2024

👀

A Timely Survey on Vision Transformer for Deepfake Detection

Zhikan Wang, Zhongyao Cheng, Jiajie Xiong, Xun Xu, Tianrui Li, Bharadwaj Veeravalli, Xulei Yang

YC

0

Reddit

0

In recent years, the rapid advancement of deepfake technology has revolutionized content creation, lowering forgery costs while elevating quality. However, this progress brings forth pressing concerns such as infringements on individual rights, national security threats, and risks to public safety. To counter these challenges, various detection methodologies have emerged, with Vision Transformer (ViT)-based approaches showcasing superior performance in generality and efficiency. This survey presents a timely overview of ViT-based deepfake detection models, categorized into standalone, sequential, and parallel architectures. Furthermore, it succinctly delineates the structure and characteristics of each model. By analyzing existing research and addressing future directions, this survey aims to equip researchers with a nuanced understanding of ViT's pivotal role in deepfake detection, serving as a valuable reference for both academic and practical pursuits in this domain.

Read more

5/15/2024

A Comparative Survey of Vision Transformers for Feature Extraction in Texture Analysis

A Comparative Survey of Vision Transformers for Feature Extraction in Texture Analysis

Leonardo Scabini, Andre Sacilotti, Kallil M. Zielinski, Lucas C. Ribas, Bernard De Baets, Odemir M. Bruno

YC

0

Reddit

0

Texture, a significant visual attribute in images, has been extensively investigated across various image recognition applications. Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs), which have been successful in many computer vision tasks, are currently among the best texture analysis approaches. On the other hand, Vision Transformers (ViTs) have been surpassing the performance of CNNs on tasks such as object recognition, causing a paradigm shift in the field. However, ViTs have so far not been scrutinized for texture recognition, hindering a proper appreciation of their potential in this specific setting. For this reason, this work explores various pre-trained ViT architectures when transferred to tasks that rely on textures. We review 21 different ViT variants and perform an extensive evaluation and comparison with CNNs and hand-engineered models on several tasks, such as assessing robustness to changes in texture rotation, scale, and illumination, and distinguishing color textures, material textures, and texture attributes. The goal is to understand the potential and differences among these models when directly applied to texture recognition, using pre-trained ViTs primarily for feature extraction and employing linear classifiers for evaluation. We also evaluate their efficiency, which is one of the main drawbacks in contrast to other methods. Our results show that ViTs generally outperform both CNNs and hand-engineered models, especially when using stronger pre-training and tasks involving in-the-wild textures (images from the internet). We highlight the following promising models: ViT-B with DINO pre-training, BeiTv2, and the Swin architecture, as well as the EfficientFormer as a low-cost alternative. In terms of efficiency, although having a higher number of GFLOPs and parameters, ViT-B and BeiT(v2) can achieve a lower feature extraction time on GPUs compared to ResNet50.

Read more

6/11/2024

Self-supervised learning improves robustness of deep learning lung tumor segmentation to CT imaging differences

Self-supervised learning improves robustness of deep learning lung tumor segmentation to CT imaging differences

Jue Jiang, Aneesh Rangnekar, Harini Veeraraghavan

YC

0

Reddit

0

Self-supervised learning (SSL) is an approach to extract useful feature representations from unlabeled data, and enable fine-tuning on downstream tasks with limited labeled examples. Self-pretraining is a SSL approach that uses the curated task dataset for both pretraining the networks and fine-tuning them. Availability of large, diverse, and uncurated public medical image sets provides the opportunity to apply SSL in the wild and potentially extract features robust to imaging variations. However, the benefit of wild- vs self-pretraining has not been studied for medical image analysis. In this paper, we compare robustness of wild versus self-pretrained transformer (vision transformer [ViT] and hierarchical shifted window [Swin]) models to computed tomography (CT) imaging differences for non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) segmentation. Wild-pretrained Swin models outperformed self-pretrained Swin for the various imaging acquisitions. ViT resulted in similar accuracy for both wild- and self-pretrained models. Masked image prediction pretext task that forces networks to learn the local structure resulted in higher accuracy compared to contrastive task that models global image information. Wild-pretrained models resulted in higher feature reuse at the lower level layers and feature differentiation close to output layer after fine-tuning. Hence, we conclude: Wild-pretrained networks were more robust to analyzed CT imaging differences for lung tumor segmentation than self-pretrained methods. Swin architecture benefited from such pretraining more than ViT.

Read more

5/15/2024