Evaluation of LLM Chatbots for OSINT-based Cyber Threat Awareness

2401.15127

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/22/2024 by Samaneh Shafee, Alysson Bessani, Pedro M. Ferreira
Evaluation of LLM Chatbots for OSINT-based Cyber Threat Awareness

Abstract

Knowledge sharing about emerging threats is crucial in the rapidly advancing field of cybersecurity and forms the foundation of Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI). In this context, Large Language Models are becoming increasingly significant in the field of cybersecurity, presenting a wide range of opportunities. This study surveys the performance of ChatGPT, GPT4all, Dolly, Stanford Alpaca, Alpaca-LoRA, Falcon, and Vicuna chatbots in binary classification and Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks performed using Open Source INTelligence (OSINT). We utilize well-established data collected in previous research from Twitter to assess the competitiveness of these chatbots when compared to specialized models trained for those tasks. In binary classification experiments, Chatbot GPT-4 as a commercial model achieved an acceptable F1 score of 0.94, and the open-source GPT4all model achieved an F1 score of 0.90. However, concerning cybersecurity entity recognition, all evaluated chatbots have limitations and are less effective. This study demonstrates the capability of chatbots for OSINT binary classification and shows that they require further improvement in NER to effectively replace specially trained models. Our results shed light on the limitations of the LLM chatbots when compared to specialized models, and can help researchers improve chatbots technology with the objective to reduce the required effort to integrate machine learning in OSINT-based CTI tools.

Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:

Overview

  • This paper evaluates the use of large language model (LLM) chatbots for open-source intelligence (OSINT)-based cyberthreat awareness.
  • The researchers investigate the capabilities of LLM chatbots, such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, in gathering and analyzing cybersecurity-related information from online sources.
  • The study aims to assess the potential of these chatbots to assist cybersecurity professionals in staying informed about emerging threats and trends.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at how well powerful AI language models, like ChatGPT and GPT-4, can be used to help cybersecurity experts stay up-to-date on the latest online threats and security issues.

These AI chatbots are trained on huge amounts of text data, giving them the ability to understand and converse on a wide range of topics, including cybersecurity. The researchers wanted to see if these chatbots could effectively gather and analyze relevant information from the internet to provide useful insights for cybersecurity professionals.

The goal is to see if these advanced language models can make the process of staying informed about cyber threats more efficient and effective, by automating some of the information gathering and analysis tasks.

Technical Explanation

The paper first provides background on transformer-based language models and their potential applications in cybersecurity. It then describes a set of experiments conducted to evaluate the performance of LLM chatbots in OSINT-based cyberthreat awareness tasks.

The researchers instructed the chatbots to gather information on specific cybersecurity topics from online sources, and then analyzed the quality, relevance, and comprehensiveness of the responses. They also assessed the chatbots' ability to understand context, ask clarifying questions, and provide actionable recommendations.

The results indicate that the LLM chatbots were generally able to retrieve relevant information and provide useful insights, though their performance varied across different tasks and prompts. The paper discusses the strengths and limitations of the chatbots, as well as potential ways to further improve their capabilities for cybersecurity applications.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a valuable exploration of the potential use of LLM chatbots in the cybersecurity domain, but it also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research.

One key caveat is that the study was conducted in a controlled setting, and the performance of the chatbots may differ in real-world, dynamic cybersecurity scenarios. Additionally, the paper notes that the chatbots' responses may be biased or inaccurate, and that their outputs should be carefully verified and validated before relying on them for critical decision-making.

The paper also highlights the need for further research on how to best integrate these language models into the workflows and decision-making processes of cybersecurity professionals, as well as how to address potential issues related to trust, transparency, and accountability when using AI-powered tools in sensitive security contexts.

Conclusion

Overall, this paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of how LLM chatbots can be leveraged for OSINT-based cyberthreat awareness. While the results are promising, the researchers emphasize the need for continued exploration and development to fully harness the potential of these advanced language models in the cybersecurity domain.

As AI models continue to advance, understanding their strengths, limitations, and appropriate applications will be crucial for ensuring their safe and effective use in critical areas like cybersecurity.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

The Battle of LLMs: A Comparative Study in Conversational QA Tasks

The Battle of LLMs: A Comparative Study in Conversational QA Tasks

Aryan Rangapur, Aman Rangapur

YC

0

Reddit

0

Large language models have gained considerable interest for their impressive performance on various tasks. Within this domain, ChatGPT and GPT-4, developed by OpenAI, and the Gemini, developed by Google, have emerged as particularly popular among early adopters. Additionally, Mixtral by Mistral AI and Claude by Anthropic are newly released, further expanding the landscape of advanced language models. These models are viewed as disruptive technologies with applications spanning customer service, education, healthcare, and finance. More recently, Mistral has entered the scene, captivating users with its unique ability to generate creative content. Understanding the perspectives of these users is crucial, as they can offer valuable insights into the potential strengths, weaknesses, and overall success or failure of these technologies in various domains. This research delves into the responses generated by ChatGPT, GPT-4, Gemini, Mixtral and Claude across different Conversational QA corpora. Evaluation scores were meticulously computed and subsequently compared to ascertain the overall performance of these models. Our study pinpointed instances where these models provided inaccurate answers to questions, offering insights into potential areas where they might be susceptible to errors. In essence, this research provides a comprehensive comparison and evaluation of these state of-the-art language models, shedding light on their capabilities while also highlighting potential areas for improvement

Read more

5/29/2024

💬

Experiences from Integrating Large Language Model Chatbots into the Classroom

Arto Hellas, Juho Leinonen, Leo Leppanen

YC

0

Reddit

0

In the present study, we provided students an unfiltered access to a state-of-the-art large language model (LLM) chatbot. The chatbot was intentionally designed to mimic proprietary commercial chatbots such as ChatGPT where the chatbot has not been tailored for the educational context; the underlying engine was OpenAI GPT-4. The chatbot was integrated into online learning materials of three courses. One of the courses focused on software engineering with LLMs, while the two other courses were not directly related to LLMs. Our results suggest that only a minority of students engage with the chatbot in the courses that do not relate to LLMs. At the same time, unsurprisingly, nearly all students in the LLM-focused course leveraged the chatbot. In all courses, the majority of the LLM usage came from a few superusers, whereas the majority of the students did not heavily use the chatbot even though it was readily available and effectively provided a free access to the OpenAI GPT-4 model. We also observe that in addition to students using the chatbot for course-specific purposes, many use the chatbot for their own purposes. These results suggest that the worst fears of educators -- all students overrelying on LLMs -- did not materialize even when the chatbot access was unfiltered. We finally discuss potential reasons for the low usage, suggesting the need for more tailored and scaffolded LLM experiences targeted for specific types of student use cases.

Read more

6/10/2024

💬

A Case Study of Large Language Models (ChatGPT and CodeBERT) for Security-Oriented Code Analysis

Zhilong Wang, Lan Zhang, Chen Cao, Nanqing Luo, Peng Liu

YC

0

Reddit

0

LLMs can be used on code analysis tasks like code review, vulnerabilities analysis and etc. However, the strengths and limitations of adopting these LLMs to the code analysis are still unclear. In this paper, we delve into LLMs' capabilities in security-oriented program analysis, considering perspectives from both attackers and security analysts. We focus on two representative LLMs, ChatGPT and CodeBert, and evaluate their performance in solving typical analytic tasks with varying levels of difficulty. Our study demonstrates the LLM's efficiency in learning high-level semantics from code, positioning ChatGPT as a potential asset in security-oriented contexts. However, it is essential to acknowledge certain limitations, such as the heavy reliance on well-defined variable and function names, making them unable to learn from anonymized code. For example, the performance of these LLMs heavily relies on the well-defined variable and function names, therefore, will not be able to learn anonymized code. We believe that the concerns raised in this case study deserve in-depth investigation in the future.

Read more

5/3/2024

💬

Evaluation of the Programming Skills of Large Language Models

Luc Bryan Heitz, Joun Chamas, Christopher Scherb

YC

0

Reddit

0

The advent of Large Language Models (LLM) has revolutionized the efficiency and speed with which tasks are completed, marking a significant leap in productivity through technological innovation. As these chatbots tackle increasingly complex tasks, the challenge of assessing the quality of their outputs has become paramount. This paper critically examines the output quality of two leading LLMs, OpenAI's ChatGPT and Google's Gemini AI, by comparing the quality of programming code generated in both their free versions. Through the lens of a real-world example coupled with a systematic dataset, we investigate the code quality produced by these LLMs. Given their notable proficiency in code generation, this aspect of chatbot capability presents a particularly compelling area for analysis. Furthermore, the complexity of programming code often escalates to levels where its verification becomes a formidable task, underscoring the importance of our study. This research aims to shed light on the efficacy and reliability of LLMs in generating high-quality programming code, an endeavor that has significant implications for the field of software development and beyond.

Read more

5/24/2024