0

0

Bridging the Visual Gap: Fine-Tuning Multimodal Models with Knowledge-Adapted Captions

    Published 11/15/2024 by Moran Yanuka, Assaf Ben Kish, Yonatan Bitton, Idan Szpektor, Raja Giryes

    Overview

    • Introduces KnowAda, a novel fine-tuning approach for multimodal models.
    • Addresses the "visual gap" where existing models struggle with complex visual reasoning.
    • Leverages knowledge-adapted captions enriched with external knowledge.
    • Demonstrates improved performance on visual question answering (VQA) tasks.
    • Shows promise for enhancing multimodal models' reasoning abilities.

    KnowAda improves VLM dense captions for better downstream training.

    1/4

    KnowAda improves VLM dense captions for better downstream training.

    Original caption: Figure 1: KnowAda identifies knowledge gaps of a VLM and adapts the dense caption accordingly. The KnowAda dense captions are better suited for downstream training of the VLM.

    Evaluation results of dense descriptions, fine-tuned with different caption sources, and using automatic and human assessment.

    1/2

    Model Captions Contradiction Precision (Auto) Contradiction Precision (Human) Contradiction Recall (Auto) Contradiction Recall (Human) Descriptiveness Precision (Auto) Descriptiveness Precision (Human) Descriptiveness Recall (Auto) Descriptiveness Recall (Human) # Words
    PaliGemma Synthetic 38.9 19 30 15.5 47.9 81 39.2 67.8 72
    PaliGemma Synthetic KA 32.4 18.4 20.8 13 55.2 81.6 36.4 61.2 54
    TinyLLaVA Synthetic 38.1 52.1 49.1 45 35.1 47.9 26.3 40.8 71
    TinyLLaVA Synthetic KA 40.2 34 40.2 22.2 48.1 66 25.4 40.9 51
    LLaVA-7B Synthetic 39.1 19.3 39.1 16.2 47.3 80.7 39.7 65.3 79
    LLaVA-7B Synthetic KA 31 15.8 31 9.3 58.4 84.2 34.5 47.4 54
    PaliGemma Human 41.6 20.4 24.6 14.9 46.7 79.6 24.6 43.2 62
    PaliGemma Human KA 38.3 18.3 22.2 13.6 49.4 81.7 28.7 38.9 65
    TinyLLaVA Human 53 51.8 39.5 38.8 31.9 51.8 22.4 31.4 100
    TinyLLaVA Human KA 42.6 34.5 19.6 12.5 46.9 65.5 19.1 22.5 53
    LLaVA-7B Human 47.2 33.4 39.7 33.2 39.4 66.6 33.7 48.1 109
    LLaVA-7B Human KA 33.7 17.1 16.7 11.2 56.9 82.9 25.8 31.8 55

    Original caption: Table 1: Dense captioning results over the test sets of DOCCI when fine-tuning on original human-annotated captions, synthetic captions, and KnowAda-adapted captions (denoted as KA) with a threshold of 20%. ā€œAutomatic (Auto)ā€ refers to model-based NLI evaluation, while ā€œHumanā€ refers to evaluations based on human labeling.

    Plain English Explanation

    KnowAda bridges the gap between visual information and model understanding, boosting performance in complex visual reasoning tasks.

    Many current multimodal models, like those explored in Vision-Language Models under Cultural Inclusive Considerations, struggle with tasks requiring deep visual understanding. They often fail to grasp the nuances of an image and how different elements relate to each other. This creates a "visual gap" limiting their effectiveness in tasks like visual question answering (VQA). Existing methods, despite improvements, fall short when the questions require understanding intricate relationships within the image or background knowledge not readily apparent. This gap highlights the need for innovative approaches that enhance the model's understanding of visual content. Similar issues are also found in general language models with respect to Detecting and Mitigating Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models, highlighting the broader challenges of factual accuracy and coherence in AI.

    KnowAda tackles this visual gap by equipping models with "knowledge-adapted captions." Instead of relying solely on basic image descriptions, these captions integrate external knowledge relevant to the scene. Imagine a picture of a historical landmark. A regular caption might simply say "A building." A knowledge-adapted caption would provide context like "The Eiffel Tower, built in 1889 by Gustave Eiffel." This extra information empowers the model to reason more effectively. By providing context and filling in background details, KnowAda helps the model bridge the visual gap and answer complex questions accurately, much like how Directed Domain Fine-tuning: Tailoring Separate Modalities specializes models to specific domains. This approach is similar to giving someone more details before asking a question, leading to more informed and accurate answers, much like how researchers are exploring whether Do More Details Always Introduce More Hallucinations?.

    Key Findings

    The paper demonstrates that fine-tuning multimodal models with knowledge-adapted captions significantly improves performance on VQA tasks. The enhanced captions provide the model with a richer understanding of the visual content, enabling it to answer questions that require more in-depth reasoning.

    Technical Explanation

    KnowAda starts by probing existing Vision-Language Models (VLMs) to identify areas where their knowledge is lacking. This analysis informs the creation of knowledge-adapted captions. The captions are generated by combining initial descriptions with relevant external knowledge retrieved using the question as a guide. This process ensures the added information is specifically targeted to enhance the model's ability to answer complex questions. The VLM is then fine-tuned using these enriched captions, enabling it to integrate the provided knowledge into its understanding of the image. The architecture itself is not modified; the improvement comes from the enriched data used for fine-tuning.

    This approach leads to improved performance in visual question answering. The model can now leverage the additional context provided by the knowledge-adapted captions to reason more effectively about the image and answer more complex questions. The implications for the field are significant. This work demonstrates a promising way to bridge the visual gap in current multimodal models, paving the way for more sophisticated visual reasoning capabilities in AI.

    Critical Analysis

    While KnowAda shows promise, it has some limitations. The effectiveness of the approach relies on the quality and relevance of the external knowledge used. Inaccurate or irrelevant knowledge could negatively impact performance. Additionally, the process of generating knowledge-adapted captions might be computationally expensive, particularly for large datasets. Bridging the Visual Gap: Fine-tuning Multimodal Models would benefit from future research exploring more efficient ways to generate and integrate external knowledge. Further investigation is also needed to understand how KnowAda generalizes to other visual reasoning tasks beyond VQA. It's also worth exploring how this approach interacts with techniques designed to mitigate hallucinations, like those described in Detecting and Mitigating Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models.

    Conclusion

    KnowAda offers a compelling strategy for enhancing the visual reasoning abilities of multimodal models. By using knowledge-adapted captions, it addresses the visual gap limiting current models. This approach improves performance on complex VQA tasks and opens up exciting avenues for future research. The potential implications extend beyond research, promising more intelligent and capable AI systems in various applications. This could lead to improvements in areas like image search, content understanding, and human-computer interaction. Further research into efficient knowledge integration and generalization to other tasks will be crucial for unlocking the full potential of this approach, as seen in the broader context of multimodal model development, such as Vision-Language Models under Cultural Inclusive Considerations.

    Full paper

    Loading...

    Loading PDF viewer...

    Read original: arXiv:2411.09018



    This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

    Total Score

    2

    Follow @aimodelsfyi on š• ā†’